Latest on MJJC

Thriller vs Bad: Track By Track

Gonetoosoon

Proud Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
1,657
Points
0
Location
Sydney, Australia
Okay. So I was comparing the structures of the different albums and thought it would be interesting to see which album people preferred on a track-by-track basis. So track one on Thriller vs track one on Bad (and so on)

So guys choose between the following..

Thriller vs Bad
-WBSS vs Bad
-Baby Be Mine vs TWYMMF
-The Girl Is Mine vs Speed Demon
-Thriller vs Liberian Girl
-Beat It vs Just Good Friends
-Billie Jean vs Another Part Of Me
-Human Nature vs Man In The Mirror
-P.Y.T vs I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-The Lady In My Life vs Dirty Diana

So in this case it is the first 9 tracks of each..


Here are mine.
-WBSS
-TWYMMF
-The Girl Is Mine
-Thriller
-Just Good Friends
-Billie Jean
-Human Nature
-P.Y.T
-Dirty Diana

So in this instance, Thriller won 6-3!

Vote Away!

What are yours?
 
Last edited:
Looks fun,

Bad
TWYMMF
Speed Demon
Thriller
Beat It
Billie Jean
Human Nature
I Just Can't Stop Loving You
Dirty Diana
 
Wanna Be Startin Somethin
The Way You Make Me Feel
Speed Demon
Liberian Girl
Beat It
Another Part Of Me and Billie Jean (It was to hard to choose between the two)
Man In The Mirror
I Just Can't Stop Loving You
Dirty Diana

Bad - 7
Thriller - 3
 
Last edited:
-WBSS
-Baby Be Mine
-The Girl Is Mine
-Liberian Girl
-Just Good Friends
-Billie Jean
-Human Nature
-I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-The Lady In My Life

Choosing between Human Nature and Man In The Mirror was very difficult. Thriller wins 6-3
 
- WBSS
- TWYMMF
- The girl is mine
- Liberian Girl
- Beat it
- Billie Jean
- Man in the Mirror
- P.Y.T.
- Dirty Diana
 
nice idea, but hard to choose:

Wanna Be Starting Something
TWYMMF
Speed Demon
Thriller
Beat It
Billie Jean
Man in The Mirror
IJCSLY
Dirty Diana

Bad wins 5-4
 
Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'
The Way You Make Me Feel
Speed Demon
Thriller
Beat It
Billie Jean
Man in the Mirror
P.Y.T. (Pretty Young Thing)
Dirty Diana

Thriller wins 5-4.
 
Thriller vs Bad

-Bad
-TWYMMF
-The Girl Is Mine
-Thriller
-Beat It
-Billie Jean
-Man In The Mirror
-I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-Dirty Diana
 
-WBSS
-TWYMMF
-Speed Demon
-Thriller
-Beat It
-Another Part Of Me
-Human Nature
-I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-Dirty Diana

Bad wins 5-4 this time... though the result could be different depending on my mood :smilerolleyes:
 
-WBBS
-TWYMMF
-The Girl Is Mine
-Thriller
-Beat It
-Billie Jean
-Human Nature
-IJCSLY
-Dirty Diana

Thriller wins 6-3
 
Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'
Baby Be Mine
The Girl is Mine
Liberian Girl
Beat it
Billie Jean
Human Nature
Pretty Young Thing
Dirty Diana

Thriller wins 7-2
 
-Bad
-TWYMMF
-The Girl Is Mine
-Thriller
-Beat It
-Billie Jean
-Man In The Mirror
-I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-Dirty Diana

Bad wins 5-4
 
Ok

WBSS
TWYMMF
Speed Demon
Liberian Girl
Beat It
Another Part of Me
Human Nature
P.Y.T.
The Lady In My Life

Thriller: 5 Bad: 4. Hmm I guess Thriller wins.
 
WBSS
TWYMMF
Speed Demon
Liberian Girl
Beat It
Another Part Of Me
Human Nature (That was HARD :bugeyed)
I Just Can't Stop Loving You
Dirty Diana!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


BAD wins 6-3 :D
 
WBSS
Baby Be Mine
The Girl Is Mine
Thriller
Beat It
Another Part of Me
Man In The Mirror
P.Y.T.
The Lady In My Life

Heh, so a 7-2 Thriller victory, and even then it was close with the ones that the Bad tracks won.
 
Ooh I like it!

-Bad
-Baby Be Mine
-The Girl Is Mine
-Thriller
-Just Good Friends
-Billie Jean
-Man In The Mirror
-P.Y.T
-The Lady In My Life

Thriller wins :D
 
WBSS
TWYMMF
The Girl Is Mine
Thriller
Beat It
Billie Jean
Man In The Mirror
I Just Can't Stop Loving You
Dirty Diana

5-3 Not as easy as I thought that was going to be
 
-Bad
-Baby Be Mine
-The Girl Is Mine
-Liberian Girl
-Beat It
-Another Part Of Me
-Human Nature
-P.Y.T
-Dirty Diana

Thriller wins 5-4 :)
 
Looks like Thriller is doing really well! I thought this would be closer! Bad is such a brilliant album, but in this instance (track by track) Thriller feels stronger to me.
 
-WBSS
-TWYMMF
-Speed Demon
-Thriller
-Beat It
-Billie Jean
-Man In The Mirror
-I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-Dirty Diana

4-5, BAD wins.
 
Gonetoosoon said:
Looks like Thriller is doing really well! I thought this would be closer! Bad is such a brilliant album, but in this instance (track by track) Thriller feels stronger to me.
Click to expand...

It's a bit unfair comparison because some strong tracks are left off from the Bad track list (eg. Smooth Criminal). It also depends on which track is paired with which one. It's hard to beat Billie Jean, Beat it and WBSST, for example. Still as an album I prefer Bad.
 
Last edited:
Bad
TWYMMF
The Girl Is Mine
Thriller
Beat It
Billie Jean
Man In The Mirror
P.Y.T
Dirty Diana

Thriller wins 5:4
 
WBSS
Baby Be Mine
The Girl Is Mine
Liberian Girl
Beat It
Another Part Of Me
Human Nature
P.Y.T.
The Lady In My Life

Thriller - 7
Bad - 2
 
- Bad
- TWYMMF
- Speed Demon
- Thriller
- Just Good Friends
- Billie Jean
- Man In The Mirror
- P.Y.T.
- Dirty Diana

Bad wins with a comfortable 6-3!
 
-Bad
-TWYMMF
-The Girl Is Mine
-Thriller
-Beat It
-Billie Jean
-Man In The Mirror
-I Just Can't Stop Loving You
-Dirty Diana

Bad wins 5-4...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top