The Discussion of MJ's Unreleased Tracks

Michael recorded the demo for "Smooth Criminal" at the Bee Gees Studio in the 80's! It was called "Al Capone" at the time.
John Barnes had a LOT of MIDI stuff in our room. You couldn't walk around
- Bruce Swedien
I remember reading this back in the day. On harmonycentral iirc, right?

I wonder why Bruce said what he said. We know that both songs have existed in 1985 with complete and different (guide) vocals. 🤔
 
I found another message from John Barnes on if Buffalo Bill was complete.

Never completed. I’d enjoy working on it along with several others from that time period. Bill Bottrell and I understand what we did and what Michael was going for. Maybe one day...He sang the chorus’. There probably is a guide vocal on the Original master.

He confirms Michael sang the chorus with a possible guide vocal. This goes back to me saying the production was complete but not the vocals.
There's supposedly a version with the Jackson bros on BV.

Was JB aware of how further the track was developed during the Victory sessions?
 
There's supposedly a version with the Jackson bros on BV.

Was JB aware of how further the track was developed during the Victory sessions?
The brothers probably came in later to lay bgvs but Michael probably discarded the track early on. Most of the outtakes from Victory notated all the brothers singing on backgrounds.

John was with Michael almost everyday from 1983 to 1986.....if the song progressed, it was during later years since it was set aside to be worked on for BAD and discarded again. John never mentions the song being complete during any later session
 
Last edited:
Little we do know on what made it to Westlake, and how many of those were worked with Q and Bruce.

Btw, why nobody has asked those yet who were there (especially Matt Forger or Russ Ragsdale)?
 
Little we do know on what made it to Westlake, and how many of those were worked with Q and Bruce.

Btw, why nobody has asked those yet who were there (especially Matt Forger or Russ Ragsdale)?
What songs did make it to Westlake? Just askin
 
The brothers probably came in later to lay bgvs but Michael probably discarded the track early on. Most of the outtakes from Victory notated all the brothers singing on backgrounds.

John was with Michael almost everyday from 1983 to 1986.....if the song progressed, it was during later years since it was set aside to be worked on for BAD and discarded again. John never mentions the song being complete during any later session
Some people insist he revisited it for Dangerous too.

But I do agree, so many songs and ideas probably definitely lay with Quincy and co. Without him involved, there's so many tracks greyed out and locked for estate access.
 
Some people insist he revisited it for Dangerous too.

But I do agree, so many songs and ideas probably definitely lay with Quincy and co. Without him involved, there's so many tracks greyed out and locked for estate access.
I heard about that but no one confirmed it was revisited during that time. Quincy is sitting on songs as well as John Barnes.
 
Whatever "rough mix from 1990" means. Was it (re)worked in 1990 or just quickly mixed from existing older multitracks?🤔
I assume it was possibly reworked, but don't quote me on that
I feel like it’s the same as DBMR. He worked on that from Thriller to Dangerous with little to no updates.
 
Last edited:
Is there some other source for Buffalo Bill being worked on in the 90's beyond some random bloke who said it and has been inactive for almost a year? I'm not buying it otherwise. Anyone can easily lie about stuff like this like we've seen on this thread many times.
 
Is there some other source for Buffalo Bill being worked on in the 90's beyond some random bloke who said it and has been inactive for almost a year? I'm not buying it otherwise. Anyone can easily lie about stuff like this like we've seen on this thread many times.
None of us actually believe it, I'm just mentioning it's been said.
 
John Barnes on Roger Troutman
He worked with us on several early Bad tracks. It wasn't kept but it felt and sounded great. Tomboy and Al Capone.


On if he's featured on the Bad25 version of Al Capone
No he is not.
Does that mean there is a more advanced version of Al Capone than the one released ?
 
I say this every few months on here, but I would love a finished version of Don't Be Messin' Round. The vibe on the demo we have is so fresh and positive, I feel elated every time I listen to it

Please let Michael have come back to this one
He worked on it for basically every single adult solo album. There's no doubt that there is a more advanced version out there.
 
More from John Barnes -

We worked in Los Angeles and the Valley. I also worked in studios in different cities traveled to with the Victory Tour. My full time job was working in studio with Michael for many things. I developed and recorded many songs, worked with New Technology, developing New Sounds from the end of Thriller to Dangerous. Many people have worked on sessions with MJ. almost no one worked with him like I did. I've worked with him many times since then including Bahrain as well. As of this point I have not worked on anything with the estate. I will be sharing many experiences and thoughts soon. Buffalo Bill is one of the first complete songs I did for and with Michael. It is difficult listening to people speak as experts who were not as involved as they would have the public believe.

I wonder who that last sentence was in reference to. Brad Sundberg comes to mind.
 
More from John Barnes -

We worked in Los Angeles and the Valley. I also worked in studios in different cities traveled to with the Victory Tour. My full time job was working in studio with Michael for many things. I developed and recorded many songs, worked with New Technology, developing New Sounds from the end of Thriller to Dangerous. Many people have worked on sessions with MJ. almost no one worked with him like I did. I've worked with him many times since then including Bahrain as well. As of this point I have not worked on anything with the estate. I will be sharing many experiences and thoughts soon. Buffalo Bill is one of the first complete songs I did for and with Michael. It is difficult listening to people speak as experts who were not as involved as they would have the public believe.

I wonder who that last sentence was in reference to. Brad Sundberg comes to mind.
If true, that would seem to echo Bottrell's comment about getting a lock/locker for tapes during Dangerous.
 
Didn't Bill say this about the Bad recording session as well? How Brad came in and took the tapes without knowledge back to Westlake?
I believe he said it occurred slightly before his dismissal from Bad, so for Dangerous, he had a lock/locker for his tapes. I could be misremembering slightly, though, which is why I'm trying to archive Bill's tweets before they go Houdini on us.
 
I believe he said it occurred slightly before his dismissal from Bad, so for Dangerous, he had a lock/locker for his tapes. I could be misremembering slightly, though, which is why I'm trying to archive Bill's tweets before they go Houdini on us.
I do remember the locker bit......it's somewhere in this thread.

I think John was talking about Brad
 
Back
Top