New interview with Bernard Belle (talks about creative process behind RTT, WYWTOM and Privacy)

mjjfan81

Proud Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2025
Messages
4
Points
3
Location
Uk
Bass Player Online Newsletter

Interview by Gerard Thompson


Grammy winning multi-instrumentalist, songwriter and producer Bernard Belle tragically passed away in 2022 at only 57. Shortly before his untimely death we had conducted an interview with Belle for Bass Player, which we are now publishing as an exclusive for our quarterly BP newsletter.

The Englewood, New Jersey native first came to national attention as a guitarist with the same legendary group, the Manhattans with which his sister performed in the late 1970s. But he is perhaps best remembered for his work as part of the famed New Jack Swing era, often with producer Teddy Riley. He co-wrote Michael Jackson’s smash “Remember The Time,” and produced or wrote for such luminary acts as Today, Guy, Bobby Brown, Whitney Houston and Glenn Jones. And of course he was heavily involved in many of the biggest songs and albums of his sister.

After dedicating his life to Christ in 1994, Belle turned more to Gospel, but for a while, he was one of the most sought after songwriters in R&B. Below is an extract from our chat with the renowned songwriter:

Bass Player: Who were you influences as a songwriter and musician?

Bernard Belle: Oh, so many. Too many to list in full. We came from a very musical family and God blessed us with many gifts. I would grow up listening to all sorts, Aretha, Earth Wind & Fire, Rufus, all the greats, man. Just great, great music.

BP: What about the bass playing? Who informed you on that front?

BB: Marshall Jones from the Ohio Players was a big one. Mr Larry Graham. Bootsy (Collins, Parliament/Funkadelic). These were the guys. They understood the bottom. They understood when to play and when to not. They were my education.

BP: How did you go from playing guitar in your sisters band to working with some of the biggest names in the industry?
BB: Well, it wasn't overnight - I paid my dues. But it was a family affair, man. Regina (Belle, a Grammy Award-winning singer in her own right) was getting more recognition and kind of making waves. The Manhattens were looking for a guitarist and Regina was their backing singer. She kind of got me the gig and that's how I started out. It wasn't my big break, but it was like a domino effect and got me in the industry.

BP: You were instrumental in pioneering the New-Jack-Swing sound with Teddy Riley. How did that collaboration come about?
BB: We went way back. He was brought in to produce an album for my band Today. And the creative juices just started flowing, man. He was such a cool cat and such a visionary. He doesn't get enough credit, he really could do anything he put his mind to.

BP: And did you start writing songs together right away?
BB: Not really. My first published work was actually on a Boy George album (laughs).

BP: A million miles away from the New-Jack-Swing movement then?
BB: Oh yeah man. But we did our album (with Today) after that. Teddy was great at getting the best out of everybody and working together towards a common goal. That was part of his greatness and was his gift. Not everyone has that ability, it's not as easy as it sounds to unite people, the right musicians, towards making something that's actually worth listening to.

BP: How did you first come to work with Michael Jackson?
BB: Teddy (Riley) contacted me about coming up with some instrumentals and beats and things for Mike. I had about ten tracks I sent him and he chose two to work on (which ended up being Remember The Time and Why You Wanna Trip On Me from Jackson's multi-platinum 1992 opus "Dangerous").

BP: How involved was Jackson in the creative process?
BB: Michael was great y'know, he would always say 'there's no room in the studio for ego, you leave that at the door'. And he lived by his advice. Sometimes he would place a lot of trust in you and you'd feel the weight of that responsibility in a way. You're not just working for anybody here, he was the biggest star on the planet, and a total musical genius, and so for someone like that to give you that amount of trust is amazing, but also daunting at the same time.

BP: Did you write the songs together or did he commission you to write for him?
BB: A bit of both. Each time was different. With Remember The Time I handed him and Teddy the instrumental and Michael went away and wrote the melody line and the lyrics. Then with Trip, he asked me to write something in his style. He said he wanted Dangerous to be more socially conscious and aware, so I wrote lyrics I thought he would sing and presented them to him in his style. He loved it and added his own touches with Teddy. The drum loop and those harmonies I think were all Mike. He did great on that, it felt like a true collaboration, in the sense that he took what I did, and just made it better.

BP: And you worked with him again on his final studio album Invincible, right?
BB: That was one of the first songs I think he did with myself and Rodney Jerkins. Rodney called me one day - he was a big fan of Dangerous and wanted to see what we could do. Michael told me he wanted to do a song about the paparazzi and it was just after Princess Diana had died, maybe like a year or so after. Michael had some ideas and asked me to go from there.

BP: So you presented him with an instrumental again?
BB: Yes, but under his instruction. He said he wanted something rocky, but with a chugging beat. He kind of beatboxed to me, like he does, the kind of rhythm he was after. I came back with my instrumental and he loved it, especially the little camera click loop we did, he loved that. I had some lyrics written out and would kind of mimic singing it to him in his style. He changed a bit of that, kind of re-wrote some of my lyrics, swapped some lines around and came up with some of his own. It was all very collaborative. I was surprised about the Princess Diana references, I didn't think he would go there, but he was really effected by what had happened to her and I think he wanted to shine a light on her treatment at the hands of the paparazzi.


BP: Did operating at that level change you as a musician?
BB: It can't not, man. It was life-changing. But it was lightning in a bottle, that whole time. Teddy, Face (songwriter Babyface), myself, Bobby (Brown), Michael, Keith (singer/songwriter Keith Sweat). That whole scene - there was just an abundance of talent and it was all leading somewhere. It was such exciting times and we all came out better musicians, better songwriters, better artists than we were before.
 
Sounds like all he did was change a few lyrics.
No he did not do just that.
Reading seems difficult for you, doesn't it?


This interview is pure gold.
It shows that a lot of the threads in this forum, especially regarding Invincible, wrongly belittle MJ's portion in the creative process.

And the three examples Bernard is talking about (RTT, Trip & Privacy) are often used as some of the "worst offenders" when there's talk about how "MJ just came in and sang his lines"...
There those folks have it - straight from the horses mouth:

RTT - "Michael went away and wrote the melody line and the lyrics"

Trip - "He (MJ) added his own touches with Teddy. The drum loop and those harmonies I think were all Mike. He did great on that, it felt like a true collaboration, ..."

Privacy
- Regarding the music: MJ beatboxed Bernard what he was after (Beat it, Way You Love Me, comes to mind). Bernard translates that into an instrumental.
- Regarding the lyrics: Bernard had some lyrics written out. "He (MJ) changed a bit of that, kind of re-wrote some of my lyrics, swapped some lines around and came up with some of his own. It was all very collaborative. I was surprised about the Princess Diana references..."
 
Last edited:
So that mistake about Princess Diana death date... it was made by Michael after all.... Damn, that's sad...

I hoped this was one of the songs, he didn't really contribute....

But he obviously co-wrote it
 
it seems Bernard understood Michael more than Teddy did. He was able to write tailor-made music for Michael, whereas Teddy presented him just (imho) "his own style".
 
- Regarding the music: MJ beatboxed Bernard what he was after (Beat it, Way You Love Me, comes to mind). Bernard translates that into an instrumental.
- Regarding the lyrics: Bernard had some lyrics written out. "He (MJ) changed a bit of that, kind of re-wrote some of my lyrics, swapped some lines around and came up with some of his own. It was all very collaborative. I was surprised about the Princess Diana references..."

All it says is that he beatboxed the basic melody and rewrote some of the lyrics. Bernard Belle did the heavy lifting.
 
He didn't make a mistake with the date of her death, because "cold winter night" could reflect his inner state of mind when he learned of her death.

That's a reach, imo. Anybody would assume "cold, winter night" was when the friend he talks about in the song died. MJ purposefully put in the wrong time period to keep the lyrics ambiguous, and also to allude to the 1993 strip search, which was on a cold, winter night.
 
Kinda hilarious that we have literal confirmation that MJ came up with the melody, the rhythm, and the concept, then contributed lyrics, and some people are still saying, “He didn’t do much.” Literally that’s the exact opposite of what’s being shared here lmao. I’m the first one to say that MJ took undue credit in many situations, but objectively this is a situation where he is integrally involved in a song’s creation.
 
I’m the first one to say that MJ took undue credit in many situations, but objectively this is a situation where he is integrally involved in a song’s creation.

Maybe you'd be right if there weren't literally six people credited with writing this song.
 
That's a reach, imo. Anybody would assume "cold, winter night" was when the friend he talks about in the song died. MJ purposefully put in the wrong time period to keep the lyrics ambiguous, and also to allude to the 1993 strip search, which was on a cold, winter night.
That could be true, because this is also about photos, although Privacy is primarily a paparazzi song and doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the allegations. And it's certainly true that his privacy was massively violated by these photos.

In Chicago 1945, a similar description to "cold winter night" can be found: "cold windy night"
Three girls disappeared, on a cold windy night
This is used to depict states of mind in order to better convey feelings. This is absolutely nothing unusual.
 
Last edited:
You can tell MJ at least penned that second verse, because a) of how autobiographical it is - I didn't believe for one second that his co-writers would be writing about Princess Diana and b) MJ's questionable use of the English language. It's typical MJ stream-of-consciousness, jumbled thoughts lyrics 101. lol
 
One songwriter seems to contradict another.

For example, according to Bernard Belle, Michael Jackson wrote the melody line and the lyrics of the 'Remember The Time' song.

But, according to Teddy Riley (in his Los Angeles Times 1996 Interview}, Teddy Riley himself wrote the melody line and the lyrics of that song.
He didn't make a mistake with the date of her death, because "cold winter night" could reflect his inner state of mind when he learned of her death.
Privacy is primarily a paparazzi song and doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the allegations.
The "my pride was snatched away" line comes right after that, and this clearly shows that both lines together refer to the Neverland strip search that took place in December (1993).
 
According to Genius, Slash actually played his guitar part:

Similar to “Leave Me Alone” and “Tabloid Junkie”, this is a song asking people to give him privacy. It is sung in a strained, almost angry voice. This is a very interesting song, with references to Princess Diana and Respect. The Song also features an interlude with slash playing an amazing guitar solo.
 
Whatever the case I think it's a huge missed oppurtunity to make 'Privacy' so ambigious regarding Princess Diana.. Her death is a great example of the dangers of paparazzi imo.
 
No the working title was indeed „drips“:
Because MJ originally wanted to raise awareness about STD (sexually transmitted diseases).
There is a version with a complete different vocal take (ala „Starlight“).
In this version MJ sings that everybody should use condoms & be extra hygienic, so everybody „stops dripping“ …
I‘m in possession of this very rare demo.
When someone is willing to meet up at the next „In The Studio“ event and can provide legal proof that he/she is completely free of any sexual diseases I‘m willing to share with that person..
You will recognize me, as I will be wearing a Trenchcoat with a red rose on my collar..
 
3I6J7SF7_o.gif
 
It was shortened lol. "Why You Wanna Trip on Me" is too long to write over and over again

'Why You Wanna Trip on Me' is indeed long for a title, that's why I think it was originally called 'Trip' (and that's what they called it) and eventually made longer to not compete with 'Jam' or something
 
In the leaked footage of MJ picking the tracklist for Dangerous they also wrote 'Trip' instead of 'WYWTOM ', so it probably wasn't shortened but the original or working title
'Why You Wanna Trip on Me' is indeed long for a title, that's why I think it was originally called 'Trip' (and that's what they called it) and eventually made longer to not compete with 'Jam' or something
During the making of an album, producers and songwriters tend to call their songs with shortened names for convenience.

That was also the case for the 'Why You Wanna Trip On Me' song.

During the making of the 'Dangerous' album, that song was being called 'Trip' (Teddy Riley also used to call it 'Trippin'').
 
Back
Top