Murray Trial - All media reports/articles - Merged - No discussion

Defense of Michael Jackson’s doctor to shift to doctor’s positive traits as case winds down

By Associated Press, Updated: Wednesday, October 26, 8:28 AM
LOS ANGELES — After weeks of hearing prosecutors and witnesses cast the physician charged in Michael Jackson’s death as a bad doctor, defense attorneys will shift the case to some of Dr. Conrad Murray’s positive traits as the case nears its close.

Murray’s defense team plans to call up to five character witnesses Wednesday who will likely speak about the Houston-based cardiologist’s care and life-saving abilities. The attorneys did not name the witnesses, but they are expected to be Murray’s patients.
The flurry of character witnesses come as defense attorneys wind down their case. They told a judge Tuesday that after the character witnesses, they will only call two experts to try to counter prosecution experts who said Murray acted recklessly by giving Jackson the anesthetic propofol as a sleep aid.

Defense attorneys could rest their case Thursday. They have already called nine witnesses, including a doctor and nurse practitioner who treated Jackson but refused his requests to help him obtain either an intravenous sleep aid or propofol.

Murray, 58, has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter. He faces up to four years behind bars and the loss of his medical license if convicted.
His attorneys contend Jackson was desperate for sleep and gave himself the fatal dose of propofol when his doctor left the room. They attempted to argue that Jackson would have been indebted to concert promoter AEG Live for nearly $40 million if his shows were canceled, but a judge blocked any mention of the figure to the jury Tuesday.
Instead, jurors heard from two witnesses who knew Jackson and described their interactions with the singer in the months before his death.

Nurse Cherilyn Lee testified about trying to help Jackson gain more energy in early 2009 to prepare for rehearsals for his planned series of comeback concerts. She said the singer complained he couldn’t sleep, and on Easter Sunday asked her to help him obtain Diprivan, a brand name for propofol.
Lee, at times tearful, said she initially didn’t know about the drug. But after asking a doctor about it and reading a reference guide, Lee said she tried to convince Jackson it was too dangerous to use in his bedroom.
“He told me that doctors have told him it was safe,” Lee testified of Jackson’s request for the anesthetic. “I said no doctor is going to do this in your house.”
The singer, however, insisted that he would be safe as long as someone monitored him, she said.

By Murray’s own admission, he left Jackson’s bedside on the morning of his death. When he returned, Jackson was unresponsive, according to his interview with police two days after Jackson’s death on June 25, 2009.
The physician said he only left Jackson’s bedside for two minutes, although his own attorneys have suggested it might have been longer. Phone records show Murray made or received several calls in the hour before Murray summoned help.

Lee acknowledged that she told detectives that she had told Jackson, “No one who cared or had your best interest at heart would give you this.”
After refusing to help Jackson obtain propofol, she never saw the singer again.

Another defense witness, AEG Live President and CEO Randy Phillips, said Jackson appeared to have total confidence in Murray during meetings in early June, just a weeks before the “This Is It” concerts were to debut in London.
Jackson had missed some rehearsals and there were complaints from the show’s choreographer that the singer didn’t seem focused. A meeting was convened to discuss Jackson’s health, and Murray reassured Phillips and others that the singer was healthy and would be able to perform.
“It was very obvious that Michael had great trust” in Murray, Phillips said.

Phillips said he attended Jackson’s final rehearsal and was impressed.
“I had goose bumps,” he said, adding that wasn’t a typical reaction. “I am as cynical as you can be about this business.”
After the rehearsal, Phillips said he walked Jackson to his vehicle, which was waiting to take him to the rented mansion. “He said, ‘You got me here. Now I’m ready. I can take it from here,’” Phillips recounted.
By the time Jackson and security arrived at the home, Murray had already arrived at the house and was waiting to help the singer get to sleep.

AP Special Correspondent Linda Deutsch contributed to this report. Anthony McCartney can be reached at http://twitter.com/mccartneyAP.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...0/26/gIQAbD51HM_story.html?wprss=rss_national
 
Character witnesses speak on Murray's behalf
By Alan Duke, CNN
October 26, 2011 -- Updated 1657 GMT (0057 HKT)

Los Angeles (CNN) -- After 17 days of hearing about how pop star Michael Jackson died under Dr. Conrad Murray's care, jurors began hearing Wednesday from people who say the doctor saved lives.

"He's the best doctor I've ever been to," said Gerry Causey, a 68-year-old former patient of the man accused of causing Jackson's death.
"And I just don't think he did what he's being accused of," Causey said under cross-examination by the prosecution.

Much of the prosecution's case has tried to demonstrate that Murray gave reckless and incompetent medical treatment as Jackson's personal doctor in the last months of his life.

Causey met Murray 11 years ago when he was rushed to a Las Vegas hospital with a heart attack, but they' became friends since then, he testified.
"It's because of Dr. Murray, the way he cares for you, the way he makes you feel," Causey said.
Prosecutors contend that Murray abandoned his patients in Las Vegas and Houston, Texas, for the $150,000 a month Jackson had promised him.
"There's no way, he's not greedy," Causey said. "He doesn't charge me my deductable, never has."

Las Vegas heart patient Andrew Guest, who followed Causey on the witness stand Wednesday, said Murray "makes sure you're ok during the procedure."
"That man sitting there is the best doctor I've ever seen," Guest testified.

The character witnesses include also Ruby Mosley, a patient at Murray's Houston clinic.

Two medical experts for the defense, including anesthesiologist Dr. Paul White, are expected to follow Thursday and possibly Friday. This would set the stage for closing arguments and jury deliberations early next week, although it's possible that could come Friday.


The promoter of Jackson's ill-fated "This Is It" tour testified Tuesday that Jackson's fear that producers would "pull the plug" on the shows if the singer missed more rehearsals was unfounded.
"No one on our end was ever contemplating pulling the plug," said Randy Phillips, the head of AEG Live.

Murray's lawyers contend Jackson self-administered the overdose of drugs that killed him in a "desperate desire to get to sleep," because he feared without rest he would miss his next rehearsal and trigger the cancellation of his comeback concerts.
If the tour was canceled, Jackson would have to pay for all of the production and rehearsal costs, Phillips said, although the judge would not let him tell jurors how much that might have been. Defense lawyer Ed Chernoff estimated the cost to be about $40 million, leaving him "a very, very poor man," but it was not while the jury was present.

Concert director Kenny Ortega sent Phillips an e-mail five days before Jackson's death, referring to Jackson's fear the company would cancel the tour. The e-mail triggered a meeting with Jackson and Murray to address Ortega's concerns about Jackson's "lack of focus" and missed rehearsals, with the debut of his London shows just three weeks away.
He and Ortega were satisfied when Jackson told them "You build the house and I will put on the door and paint it," suggesting he would be ready, Phillips testified.
Also at the meeting, Phillips told Murray that he wanted to make sure Murray knew about Jackson's visits to another doctor, dermatologist Dr. Arnold Klein. "Because he's his principal physician, I thought he should know," he said.
Phillips said he was concerned because Jackson "seemed a little distracted and not focused" in a meeting after a visit to Klein's Beverly Hills clinic.

The defense contends Jackson became addicted to the painkiller Demerol in his frequent visits to Klein in the three months before his death. His withdrawal from the Demerol, which Murray was unaware of, would explain why Jackson could not sleep the day he died, the defense contends.

Earlier Tuesday, a nurse who tried to treat Jackson's insomnia with natural remedies testified that Jackson told her that doctors assured him using the surgical anesthetic propofol at home to induce sleep was safe as long as he was monitored.
Jackson died two months after that conversation with nurse Cherilyn Lee, from what the coroner ruled was an overdose of propofol, combined with sedatives.

Prosecutors contend Murray's use of propofol to treat Jackson's insomnia in his home was reckless, in part because he did not have proper equipment to monitor his patient and he abandoned him to make phone calls.
Lee's testimony was briefly delayed as she was overcome with emotion. "I'm feeling really, really dizzy," Lee said. "This is just very sensitive to me."
Lee used IV drips loaded with vitamins, "sophisticated" vitamin smoothies and bedtime teas to treat Jackson's insomnia, but Jackson became frustrated when her natural remedies failed to make him sleep, she said.
"He said 'I'm telling you the only thing that's going to help me sleep right away is the Diprivan and can you find someone to help me to sleep?'" Lee said. Diprivan is a brand name for propofol.
After some quick research, the nurse warned Jackson that it was dangerous to use propofol at home, Lee testified.
Jackson was not deterred, she said, even after she asked him "but what if you don't wake up?"
Deputy District Attorney David Walgren asked her, "And he responded, 'I will be OK, I only need someone to monitor me with the equipment while I sleep'?"
"Yes, that's exactly what he said," Lee said.

Murray had already agreed to serve as Jackson's private physician and had ordered his first supplies of propofol for Jackson more than a week before Jackson asked Lee for help getting the drug.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/10/26/j...ad-murray-trial/index.html?section=cnn_latest


Witness says Michael Jackson doctor was caring and thorough, not motivated by money

LOS ANGELES — A former patient of the doctor charged in Michael Jackson’s death told jurors Wednesday the physician is caring and not motivated by money.
Gerry Causey, of Cedar City, Utah, was called as the first of five character witnesses by attorneys for Dr. Conrad Murray. Causey said Murray treated him for a heart attack 11 years ago, and he remains friends with the cardiologist.

Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Michael Jackson’s death.

Causey said he was not put to sleep at his request while Murray implanted a stent after fully explaining the procedure to him.
“I know his love, his compassion, his feelings for his patients,” Causey said. “He’s the best doctor I’ve ever been to.”
Murray, 58, last treated Causey in 2008. Causey said the doctor didn’t charge him his deductible for office visits.
“I just don’t think he did what he’s been accused of,” said Causey, who described Murray as his best friend.

Another witness, Dennis Hix of Banning, Calif., said Murray performed a stent procedure for him for free.

Murray agreed to become Jackson’s personal physician for $150,000 a month but was never paid because the singer died before the contract was signed.
Prosecutors have contended that Murray was heavily in debt and initially sought $5 million to treat Jackson as he prepared for a series of lucrative comeback concerts.

Murray has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter in Jackson’s June, 25, 2009, death. Authorities contend Murray gave Jackson a fatal dose of the anesthetic propofol in the singer’s bedroom. Defense attorneys claim the singer gave himself the fatal dose.

Another character witness, Andrew Guest, echoed Causey’s comments about Murray’s skill and care.
“He makes sure you’re OK, during the procedure, after the procedure,” said Guest, a locksmith at a casino in Las Vegas. “I’m alive today because of that man.”

The flurry of witnesses came as defense attorneys wind down their case, which could conclude Thursday. They previously told a judge that after the character witnesses, they will call two experts to try to counter prosecution experts who said Murray acted recklessly by giving Jackson propofol as a sleep aid.

They have already called a doctor and nurse practitioner who treated Jackson but refused his requests to help him obtain either an intravenous sleep aid or propofol.

Murray’s attorneys contend Jackson was desperate for sleep so he could rehearse for his comeback shows and gave himself the fatal dose of propofol when his doctor left the room.
They attempted to argue that Jackson would have been indebted to concert promoter AEG Live for nearly $40 million if his shows were canceled, but a judge blocked any mention of the figure to the jury.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...1/10/26/gIQAbD51HM_story.html?wprss=rss_music



Dr. Conrad Murray In Tears As Patient Testifies
Posted on Oct 26, 2011 @ 12:55PM
By Jen Heger Radar Legal Editor

Dr. Conrad Murray broke down in tears as his best friend and patient testified on his behalf in the Michael Jackson death trial in a Los Angeles courtroom on Wednesday morning, RadarOnline.com is reporting. The defense called Gerry Causey from Houston, Texas to the stand as a character witness.

Causey said that Dr. Murray had saved his life as the embattled cardiologist had performed a successful angioplasty on him. Dr. Murray broke down in tears as Causey, who described the doctor as his best friend, raved about the treatment he received. Causey asserted that Dr. Murray would call his wife and would often apprise her of test results, and upcoming appointments. Causey said he received local anesthesia, and that he wasn't knocked out during the time of the procedure.

Deputy District Attorney David Walgren asked Causey if Dr. Murray ever treated him for any sleep disorders or any durg problems; Causey said no. Walgren also inquired about where Causey's procedure was performed and he said in the hospital.

Dr. Murray also broke down as another patient said that Dr. Murray was the best doctor he had ever had. Dr. Murray's defense could rest as early as Friday. Under cross examination Andrew Guest was asked if Dr. Murray had ever given him propofol in his bedroom, and he said no.

If convicted of involuntary manslaughter, Murray could receive four years behind bars.
http://www.radaronline.com/exclusives/2011/10/dr-conrad-murray-tears-patient-testifies


October 26, 2011
Dr. Murray fights tears as former patients testify
Posted: 01:58 PM ET

We haven't seen a lot of emotion from Dr. Conrad Murray for much of his involuntary manslaughter trial. For the most part, he's sat at the defense table with a stoic look on his face. But today he really turned on the waterworks as the defense paraded several of of his former patients on the stand. They all sang his praises.

Gerry Causey testified that he received excellent healthcare from Dr. Murray. During cross examination, prosecutor David Walgren asked Causey if he would still testify for his "best friend" if he thought Dr. Murray acted in gross negligence and killed Michael Jackson. Causey said that he would still be sitting in the witness box supporting Dr. Murray even if he thought Dr. Murray's negligence had killed the pop star.

Andrew Guest said he was still alive because of Dr. Murray's care. He said nothing would change his mind about the man.

Lunette Sampson testified that Dr. Murray cleared blockages in her heart and she has never had a more caring doctor.

Dennis Hix testified that Dr. Murray placed around 12 stints in his heart and he was the best doctor he has ever had.

The fifth and final patient to testify was Ruby Mosley who is also Dr. Murray's friend. Dr. Murray really had to fight back tears as Mosley testified that Dr. Murray wasn't a greedy person because he opened up a clinic in a low income area of Houston in honor of his father.

http://insession.blogs.cnn.com/2011/10/26/dr-murray-fights-tears-as-former-patients-testify/


Michael Jackson Manslaughter Trial: Patient Calls Conrad Murray "The Best Doctor I've Ever Seen"
Today 8:55 AM PDT by Gina Serpe

UPDATE 10:30 a.m.: After powering through several character witnesses, including Gerry Causey, a former patient of Murray's who was treated by the doctor 11 years and who has remained friends with him since. He declared Murray "the best doctor I've ever seen...I just don't think he did what he's been accused of."

The court took an early recess for the day due to a pressing yet unforeseen scheduling conflict. Testimony will resume tomorrow morning at 8:45 a.m. PT.

The Michael Jackson manslaughter trial hasn't been kind to Conrad Murray. But today, if the doctor's defense does their job right, that will change.

His attorneys, who are blowing through their witnesses at record speed, are expected to call five character witnesses to the stand today who will attempt to paint the doctor as a caring physician who was doing the best he could for his patient—who, incidentally, was just named Forbes' No. 1 top earning dead celebrity, with an estimated intake of $170 million last year. In any case, it's safe to say those witnesses have their work cut out for them.

Should the defense power through the five witnesses planned for today, just two will remain in their case and take the stand tomorrow.
http://uk.eonline.com/news/michael_jackson_manslaughter_trial/271641


InSession In Session
Outside the presence of the jury, Judge Pastor informed #ConradMurray of his right to testify in the case against him.

mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
Judge Pastor told Murray that it was his decision alone if he wanted to testify or not.

mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
Judge said he was telling Murray this because defense is winding down, and he will ask him whether he wants to testify after defense rests.
 
Last edited:
Defense in Conrad Murray trial down to final 2 witnesses
By Alan Duke, CNN
October 27, 2011 -- Updated 1620 GMT (0020 HKT)
Los Angeles (CNN) -- Dr. Conrad Murray's lawyers called a drug addiction specialist to the stand Thursday morning in an effort to show Michael Jackson's insomnia the day he died could have been caused by withdrawal from a drug given him by another doctor.
The defense hopes their last two witnesses will convince jurors in Murray's involuntary manslaughter trial that Michael Jackson gave himself the overdose of drugs that killed him.

After five Murray heart patients testified Wednesday that he was a good and caring doctor who saved their lives, two medical experts remain on the defense witness list. Testimony could conclude by Friday or Monday in the trial that started a month ago.

The Los Angeles County coroner ruled Jackson's June 25, 2009, death was the result of "acute propofol intoxication" in combination with several sedatives.

The defense theory is that a desperate Jackson, fearing his comeback concerts could be canceled unless he found elusive sleep, self-administered propofol that Murray was trying to wean him off of.
Prosecutors contend Murray is responsible for his death even if he did not give him the final and fatal dose because he was criminally reckless in using the surgical anesthetic to help Jackson sleep without proper precautions.

Dr. Robert Waldman, a specialist in addiction, began his testimony Thursday morning.
The defense contends Jackson became addicted to the painkiller Demerol through frequent visits to the Beverly Hills dermatology clinic of Dr. Arnold Klein in the months before his death. Murray was unaware of the addiction, and therefore unable to understand why he could not help Jackson sleep, the defense contends.

Patient: Murray very 'proactive' Defense anesthesiology expert Dr. Paul White is expected to also testify Thursday or Friday in an effort to counter testimony from prosecution anesthesiologist Dr. Steven Shafer.
Shafer concluded that the "only scenario" that fits the scientific evidence is that Jackson was on an IV drip of propofol for three hours before his death and Murray failed to notice when he stopped breathing.
Shafer conceded that it was possible that Jackson, not Murray, could have been the one to open the drip to a fatal pace, but prosecutors contend it would make no difference in Murray's guilt.

Murray cried in court Wednesday as he listened to an elderly patient tell jurors that he opened a clinic in the Acres Homes community of Houston in honor of his father, who had practiced there.
Ruby Mosley was one of five character witnesses called by Murray's lawyers Wednesday morning in an effort to counter 17 days of prosecution testimony that sometimes painted him as an incompetent and greedy doctor.
"If this man had been greedy, he never would have come to an area, a community of Acres Homes, 75% of them poor, on welfare and Social Security," Mosley said.
Murray dabbed tears from his eyes even after Mosley left the stand.
Even Randy Jackson, the late pop icon's brother, seemed touched by Mosley's testimony.

"He's the best doctor I've ever been to," said Gerry Causey, a 68-year-old former patient of the man accused of causing Jackson's death. "And I just don't think he did what he's being accused of," Causey added, under cross-examination by the prosecution.
Causey met Murray 11 years ago when he was rushed to a Las Vegas hospital with a heart attack, but they became friends since then, he testified.
"It's because of Dr. Murray, the way he cares for you, the way he makes you feel," Causey said.
Prosecutors contend that Murray abandoned his patients in Las Vegas and Houston for the $150,000 a month Jackson had promised him.
"There's no way, he's not greedy," Causey said. "He doesn't charge me my deductible, never has."

Las Vegas heart patient Andrew Guest, who followed Causey on the witness stand Wednesday, said Murray "makes sure you're OK during the procedure."
"That man sitting there is the best doctor I've ever seen," Guest testified.

Murray treated Dennis Hix by putting 14 stents into arteries around his heart 11 years ago, Hix testified.
"I'm 66, I've gone to a lot of doctors, a lot of doctors, and I've never had one that gave me the care that he did," Hix said.
Murray never charged Hix beyond what his insurance would pay, he said. "I had a type of insurance that don't hardly pay for nothing," he said. "So he did it for me free."

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/10/27/justice/california-conrad-murray-trial/?hpt=ju_c1
 
Addiction expert testifying for Jackson’s doctor says singer likely was addicted to painkiller

By Associated Press, Updated: Thursday, October 27, 7:10 PM
LOS ANGELES — An addiction expert testifying for the doctor charged in Michael Jackson’s death told jurors Thursday he believes medical records showed the singer developed an addiction to a powerful pain medicine in the months before his death.

Dr. Robert Waldman told jurors that Jackson was receiving “above-average doses” of the painkiller Demerol in the months before his death.

Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Michael Jackson’s death.
“I believe there is evidence that he was dependent on Demerol, possibly,” Waldman said. The witness said he also thinks Jackson had an addiction to opioids by May 2009, the month before his death.
Waldman said a symptom of Demerol withdrawal is insomnia. Jackson complained that he couldn’t sleep as he prepared for a series of comeback concerts.
Attorneys for Dr. Conrad Murray have suggested Jackson was undergoing withdrawal from Demerol before his death. None of the drug was found in the singer’s system when he died.

Defense attorneys contend Jackson gave himself a fatal dose of the anesthetic propofol, which they say he was taking as a sleep aid.
Authorities found propofol throughout Jackson’s body during an autopsy, and they contend Murray gave the singer a fatal dose of the drug while using it to help him sleep.

Jackson received the Demerol shots from his longtime dermatologist, Dr. Arnold Klein, who has not been accused of wrongdoing and will not be called as a witness during the trial.
Waldman said he had not treated a case of Demerol addiction in recent memory.

Murray has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter in Jackson’s June 2009 death.

The Houston-based cardiologist’s attorneys plan to call a propofol expert later Thursday.

Murray’s attorneys have yet to show evidence of how their self-administration theory would have been possible. Several prosecution experts have said the self-administration defense was improbable, and a key expert said he ruled it out completely, arguing the more likely scenario was that Murray gave Jackson a much higher dose than he has acknowledged.

The scientific testimony of Waldman and Dr. Paul White comes a day after jurors heard from five of Murray’s one-time patients, who described the cardiologist as a caring physician who performed procedures for free and spent hours getting to know them. When Ruby Mosley described Murray’s work at a clinic he founded in a poor neighborhood in Houston in memory of his father, tears welled up in the eyes of the normally stoic doctor-turned-defendant.

White and Waldman do not necessarily have to convince jurors that Jackson gave himself the fatal dose, but merely provide them with enough reasonable doubt about the prosecution’s case against Murray.

Prosecutors have portrayed Murray, 58, as a reckless physician who repeatedly broke the rules by giving Jackson propofol as a sleep aid. But jurors heard a different description of the doctor Wednesday.

Several of the character witnesses called described Murray as the best doctor they had ever seen and highlighted his skills at repairing their hearts with stents and other procedures.
“I’m alive today because of that man,” said Andrew Guest of Las Vegas, who looked at Murray. “That man sitting there is the best doctor I’ve ever seen.”
Another former patient, Gerry Causey, stopped to shake Murray’s hand in the courtroom and said the physician was his best friend.
A prosecutor noted none of them were treated for sleep issues, although Causey and others said they didn’t believe the allegations against Murray.

Defense attorneys have told Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor they expect their case to conclude Thursday. Pastor has said if that happens, closing arguments would occur next week.

AP Special Correspondent Linda Deutsch contributed to this report.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...1/10/27/gIQAeinCLM_story.html?wprss=rss_music


L.A. NOW
Southern California -- this just in
Michael Jackson 'probably' addicted to Demerol -- defense witness
October 27, 2011 | 11:29 am

Michael Jackson was “probably” addicted to Demerol provided by his Beverly Hills dermatologist, a specialist in addiction medicine told jurors Thursday at the trial of the singer’s personal physician.

Dr. Robert Waldman, testifying as a defense expert, detailed medical records that indicated dermatologist Arnold Klein injected the singer with increasingly large doses of the painkiller during offices visits for Botox and another wrinkle remover.
“I believe there’s evidence he was dependent on Demerol,” Waldman said.
“What about addicted,” a defense lawyer pressed.
“Possibly,” the witness replied, adding that based on the records and “what’s known about his public behavior, he was probably addicted to opioids.”


Dr. Conrad Murray’s defense rests on a theory that Klein hooked Jackson on Demerol a few months before his death and that the singer suffered chronic insomnia as a result of drug withdrawal.
Defense lawyers contend Jackson injected himself with a fatal dose of propofol, a surgical anesthetic, to get to sleep before important rehearsals.

Those close to Jackson told police that visits to Klein’s office left the singer woozy, but Murray claimed he never asked his famous patient for details of the treatment.

Waldman said he had no expertise in dermatology, but had consulted doctors in the field who told him the dermatological procedures Jackson was receiving -- shots of Botox and a wrinkle filler, Restylane -– did not cause the severe pain that would require such doses of Demerol.

Klein’s medical records showed Jackson had received as much as 375 milligrams of Demerol in a 90-minute period. A typical dose is 50 milligrams, he said.
The amount Klein gave Jackson would leave him “sleepy, lethargic, possibly difficult to arouse, possibly unresponsive,” Waldman said.

On cross-examination, a prosecutor implied Waldman’s conclusions were irrelevant to the manslaughter case before the jury.
“You understand there is no Demerol in the toxicology findings” from Jackson’s autopsy, asked Deputy Dist. Atty. David Walgren.
“Correct,” Waldman replied.
He also accused the expert of overreaching, by in part relying on secondhand accounts of Jackson’s behavior.
“Would you diagnose Michael Jackson as addicted to Demerol based strictly on the documents in my hand?” the prosecutor asked.
“Probably not,” Waldman acknowledged.

The defense wanted to call Klein as a witness, but prosecutors objected, saying Murray was seeking to confuse the jury by blaming another party.
Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor barred the defense from calling the dermatologist, but allowed the introduction of 36 pages of his medical records. Those records, as laid out in court, show Jackson frequently visited Klein’s office in the months leading up to his death.
Klein was among a number of physicians investigated after the pop star’s June 25, 2009, death. Only Murray was charged.

Jurors are expected to begin deliberating the case next week. If Murray is convicted of involuntary manslaughter, he faces a maximum of four years in prison
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...ichael-jackson-probably-addicted-to-drug.html
 
Last edited:
L.A. NOW
Southern California -- this just in
« Previous Post | L.A. NOW Home | Next Post »


Conrad Murray trial: Caving in to a patient's demands?
October 27, 2011 | 1:03 pm

A defense expert at the trial of Michael Jackson's personal physician acknowledged Thursday that he himself would never cave in to a patient's demand for an unsafe medical treatment, the allegation prosecutors have made against the doctor.

Dr. Robert Waldman, a specialist in addiction medicine, testified under questioning by a defense attorney that the singer was "probably" addicted to the Demerol provided by his longtime dermatologist.

But on cross-examination, a prosecutor switched the focus to the medical treatment provided by Dr. Conrad Murray, the defendant who had hired Waldman as an expert witness.
"If a patient asks you to administer a dangerous drug, a drug that could be harmful ... would you refuse to administer that drug to the patient?" Deputy Dist. Atty. David Walgren asked.
"Absolutely," Waldman replied.

Murray's defense called the expert to bolster its theory that painkiller withdrawal caused the singer's chronic insomnia. Jackson, the defense has suggested, was so concerned about getting sleep before crucial rehearsals that he injected himself with a lethal amount of a surgical anesthetic when Murray was out of the room. Prosecutors maintain Jackson stopped breathing after Murray set up an intravenous drip of propofol, a powerful drug intended for use only in hospitals and surgical suites, and then failed to monitor his vital signs.
Walgren noted that Jackson often went long stretches between visits to dermatologist Arnold Klein -- including a full week shortly before his death. If Demerol addicts could suffer withdrawal after just eight hours, how had Jackson gone many days, the prosecutor asked.

Addicts "often have multiple sources. If they can't get their main med, they will look elsewhere to get it," Waldman said, adding that Klein's records were "inadequate."
The prosecutor seized on the answer. Have you reviewed the defendant's records for Jackson, he asked the expert. As the jury has heard repeatedly, Murray kept no records in the months before Jackson died.
The judge directed the witness not to answer. "Assumes facts not in evidence," Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor said.

Under further questioning by a lawyer for Murray, Waldman hinted at the frustration the defense claims the doctor encountered when he tried to get Jackson to seek help. Waldman said the best course of treatment for an addict is an inpatient treatment center, but if the person refuses "we don't really have much choice. Hands are tied."

Murray, 58, faces a maximum of four years in prison if convicted of involuntary manslaughter. The defense's main scientific expert, Dr. Paul White, is to take the stand Thursday afternoon. Jurors are expected to begin deliberations next week.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2011/10/conrad-murray-expert-michael-jackson.html


October 27, 2011
Witness: Don't put words in my mouth
Posted: 04:28 PM ET

Looks like one of the defense's final witnesses wasn't ready to play nice with prosecutor David Walgren. During an intense cross examination Thursday, Dr. Robert Waldman accused Walgren of putting words in his mouth. The judge stepped in and told Dr. Waldman that that's how cross examinations usually work.

Walgren asked the judge to strike several of Dr. Waldman's responses because he was being "unresponsive." When Walgren asked him how many hours each week he did dialysis work, it took Dr. Waldman about a minute and a half of back and forth before he could explain.

"What you're asking me is extremely non-specific and I'm telling you honestly I don't measure," Dr. Waldman said.
It seems like Walgren was trying to imply that because Dr. Waldman also practices dialysis, he may not be most knowledgeable expert for this case. Dr. Waldman testified earlier that Michael Jackson was dependent on the painkiller Demerol, given to him by his dermatologist Dr. Arnold Klein.
Walgren was also able to attack the addiction specialist's credibility by getting him to admit that he is not board certified in addiction medicine.

Looks like one of the defense's final witnesses wasn't ready to play nice with prosecutor David Walgren. During an intense cross examination Thursday, Dr. Robert Waldman accused Walgren of putting words in his mouth. The judge stepped in and told Dr. Waldman that that's how cross examinations usually work.
Walgren asked the judge to strike several of Dr. Waldman's responses because he was being "unresponsive." When Walgren asked him how many hours each week he did dialysis work, it took Dr. Waldman about a minute and a half of back and forth before he could explain.

"What you're asking me is extremely non-specific and I'm telling you honestly I don't measure," Dr. Waldman said.
It seems like Walgren was trying to imply that because Dr. Waldman also practices dialysis, he may not be most knowledgeable expert for this case. Dr. Waldman testified earlier that Michael Jackson was dependent on the painkiller Demerol, given to him by his dermatologist Dr. Arnold Klein.

Walgren was also able to attack the addiction specialist's credibility by getting him to admit that he is not board certified in addiction medicine.
http://insession.blogs.cnn.com/2011/10/27/witness-dont-put-words-in-my-mouth/

Jackson doctor's lawyers try to shift blame
Singer's longtime dermatologist keeps being mentioned, but can't be called to testify

By ANTHONY McCARTNEY

updated 10/27/2011 7:03:18 PM ET 2011-10-27T23:03:18
Print Font: + -
LOS ANGELES — Lawyers for Michael Jackson's doctor sought to shift blame Thursday to another doctor and a drug different from the anesthetic that killed the star, calling an expert to testify that Jackson was addicted to Demerol in the months before his death.

They suggested the singer's withdrawal from the painkiller triggered the insomnia that Dr. Conrad Murray was trying to resolve when he gave Jackson the anesthetic propofol.

Murray's attorneys claim Jackson self-administered a fatal dose of propofol as a sleep aid.

Authorities contend Murray delivered the lethal dose and botched resuscitation efforts. Murray has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter in Jackson's 2009 death.

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/45060754/ns/today-entertainment/
 
Last edited:
Aphrodite Jones Reports: Nurse's Testimony Total Disaster for Conrad Murray's Defense
October 26, 2011

Yesterday was a total disaster for the Conrad Murray defense. All I can say is: Nurse Cherilyn Lee seemed to help the prosecution more than anyone thus far. In hindsight, the defense should have thought twice about calling a seemingly hostile witness who they were unable to interview prior to her testimony.

The nurse practitioner, who earned a Ph.D. in nutrition schooled via online studies, was so shaken up by the thought that propofol killed her former patient Michael Jackson, she actually appeared faint and was granted a "rest period" by the judge so she could compose herself in order to testify. When Cherilyn Lee finally appeared an hour later to take the witness stand, she substantiated her belief in holistic medicine and explained how she tried to help MJ with his sleep problems by making special smoothie drinks and giving Michael non-toxic supplements in April of 2009. Of course, the defense was rolling the dice with this witness. They called Ms. Lee in an effort to establish that MJ had prior experience with propofol, that MJ was insistent about propofol being the only substance that could "knock him out" so he could actually get a good night's sleep. And yes, nurse Lee did confirm that MJ requested the drug propofol on more than one occasion in 2009, proving that the singer was familiar with the drug and implying that Conrad Murray was the one of a string of medical professionals who had been hit up by Michael for the anesthetic ... Still, on cross examination, Ms. Lee's tearful affect seemed to impact the jury more than the defense could ever have foreseen.


The most damning testimony from Ms. Lee came when she told jurors that she warned Michael about the dangers of using propofol outside of a hospital setting and told the court that MJ insisted: "Doctors have told me that it's safe ... I just need to be monitored." Had Dr. Conrad Murray properly monitored Michael? Did he put his life in the wrong hands? That's what Nurse Cherilyn Lee seemed to be implying. Sometimes, body language is more powerful than words. This nurse was heavy-hearted, tearful and faint. Clearly she blames Murray for playing Russian roulette with MJ's life.

http://blogs.discovery.com/criminal...otal-disaster-for-conrad-murrays-defense.html
 
Defense expert to give competing version of events in Michael Jackson’s bedroom before death
By Associated Press, Updated: Friday, October 28, 9:00 AM

LOS ANGELES — Jurors hearing the involuntary manslaughter case against Michael Jackson’s doctor will hear an alternate version Friday of what may have occurred in the singer’s bedroom in the hours before his death.

Dr. Paul White, an expert in the anesthetic propofol, will finally lay out his rationale for the defense theory that Jackson somehow gave himself a fatal dose of the drug when his doctor left the room.

Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Michael Jackson’s death.
White’s testimony will likely be vigorously challenged by prosecutors, who spent four weeks laying out their case that Dr. Conrad Murray is a greedy, inept and reckless doctor who was giving Jackson propofol as a sleep aid. But cross-examination of White will be delayed until Monday to give prosecutors more time to review a new analysis prepared by the defense based on recently-conducted tests on samples taken during Jackson’s autopsy.

“This is the entire crux of the defense case,” Deputy District Attorney David Walgren said in arguing for a delay.

The judge hearing the case, which ends its fifth week on Friday, reluctantly agreed to delay the cross examination and said he is concerned about losing jurors. Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor however noted that the panel of has remained rapt throughout the trial.

“Every single member of that jury and all the alternates are paying extraordinary attention to every witness,” Pastor said.

Murray has pleaded not guilty.

White’s opinions will challenge those of the prosecution’s main expert, Dr. Steven Shafer, who testified that the only scenario he believes explains Jackson’s death is that Murray placed Jackson on an IV drip and left the room after he thought the singer was sleeping peacefully.

Murray told police he left Jackson’s bedside, but claims he only gave the singer a small dose of propofol the morning of Jackson’s death. He said he left the room and returned after two minutes to find the pop superstar unresponsive.

Murray’s defense attorneys have repeatedly claimed that Jackson somehow gave himself the fatal dose, but it will be up to White to explain how that would be possible.

Defense attorney J. Michael Flanagan said that the new models White will show jurors on Friday will offer different simulations about the drugs propofol and sedative lorazepam. They are based on a new computer program and updated test results.
Flanagan did not reveal what conclusions White drew from the new models, or whether they would change his testimony.

White is a retired researcher and professor who performed clinical studies of propofol for years before it was approved for usage by the Food and Drug Administration in 1989. He said he was initially reluctant to become involved in the case, but after reading through more than a dozen expert reports, he couldn’t figure out how others came to the conclusion that Murray would have had to leave Jackson on a propofol IV drip for the singer to have died with the anesthetic still coursing through his body.

He said the others’ theories didn’t make sense based on Murray’s statement to police.
“I thought that there were questions if in fact Murray had administered the drugs that he described in his conversations with the police department in the doses he described, I would not have expected Michael Jackson to have died,” White said.
He continued to work on the case after meeting with Murray, although White was not allowed to testify about his conversations with the Houston-based cardiologist.

Flanagan early in White’s testimony on Thursday asked the doctor to address “the elephant in the room” — whether he could justify Murray’s actions if he left Jackson hooked to a propofol IV and then left the room.

“Absolutely not,” White replied

http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...1/10/28/gIQAYNyTOM_story.html?wprss=rss_music
 
Defense expert says evidence shows Michael Jackson gave himself fatal dose of anesthetic

By Associated Press, Updated: Friday, October 28, 9:41 PM
LOS ANGELES — An anesthesia expert testifying for the doctor charged in Michael Jackson’s death told jurors Friday he believes evidence and test results show the pop superstar gave himself a fatal injection of an anesthetic.

Dr. Paul White said the self-injection theory is the only one supported by the physician’s statement to police and by all the evidence found at Jackson’s rented mansion.

Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Michael Jackson’s death.
White said he saw no evidence supporting the prosecution theory that Jackson’s doctor, Conrad Murray, was infusing the singer with propofol using an IV.

The researcher said the evidence recovered in Jackson’s bedroom was more consistent with the singer receiving the powerful anesthetic through an injection. He said he believes Jackson somehow gave himself a 25-milligram dose of the drug between 11:30 a.m. and noon on June 25, 2009, when Murray found the singer unresponsive.
White — the defense’s strongest witness and likely its last — will undergo cross-examination Monday. His testimony is expected to be vigorously challenged by prosecutors, who spent four weeks laying out their case that Murray is a greedy, inept and reckless doctor who was giving Jackson propofol as a sleep aid in the singer’s bedroom.

Propofol is not intended as a sleep aid and, medical groups say, should be administered only in a hospital or surgical setting with advanced monitoring equipment.

White’s testimony directly contradicts the theory by his colleague and collaborator, Dr. Steven Shafer, who testified for the prosecution. Shafer told jurors he believed Jackson’s doctor used an IV drip of propofol and said that was the only way to explain the high levels of the drug found in the singer’s body.
Shafer ruled out the self-administration theory during his Oct. 20 testimony, saying Jackson was asleep and the theory the singer could give himself the drug was “crazy.”

But White noted there were no IV bags or lines found in Jackson’s bedroom that showed propofol residue throughout the entire line. He also said the levels of propofol found in Jackson’s urine did not support the IV theory.
Murray has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter.
White’s testimony was expected to end Murray’s defense case after 16 witnesses. Cross-examination was delayed until Monday to give prosecutors more time to review a new analysis prepared by the defense based on recently conducted tests of samples taken during Jackson’s autopsy.

White told jurors he saw no evidence that Murray left Jackson on an IV drip of propofol when he left the room and returned to find the singer unresponsive.
He said the singer would have had to lie completely still to keep from disturbing the bottle under that scenario, and he has never heard of anyone using an IV saline bag to suspend a bottle of propofol for a drip.

White noted all bottles of the drug come with a tab on the side, which can be used to hang them from an IV stand.
One of Jackson’s bodyguards reported seeing a bottle of propofol in a saline bag when he responded to the singer’s bedroom after Murray summoned for help. A coroner’s investigator said she found an empty propofol bottle inside an IV bag among several bags of items containing medical equipment and several drugs in Jackson’s closet, but she did not photograph the bottle in the bag.
White said under Shafer’s IV administration scenario, the propofol bottle would have had to run dry right at the moment of Jackson’s death.

White performed clinical studies of propofol for years before it was approved for usage by the Food and Drug Administration in 1989.
He initially was reluctant to become involved in the Jackson case. But White said that after reading more than a dozen expert reports, he couldn’t figure out how others came to the conclusion that Murray would have had to leave Jackson on a propofol IV drip for the singer to die with the anesthetic still coursing through his body.

AP Special Correspondent Linda Deutsch contributed to this report.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...0/28/gIQAYNyTOM_story.html?wprss=rss_national


California: Witness Testifies Jackson Caused His Own Death
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Published: October 28, 2011

Lawyers for Michael Jackson’s doctor dropped the bombshell Friday they have been hinting at for months — an expert opinion accusing the singer of causing his own death. Dr. Paul White, the defense’s star scientific witness, said Mr. Jackson injected himself with propofol after an initial dose by Dr. Conrad Murray wore off. Dr. White said he accepted Dr. Murray’s statement that he gave only 25 milligrams of propofol. He said Mr. Jackson could have injected himself with another 25 milligrams during the time Dr. Murray, who is charged with involuntary manslaughter, has said he left the room.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/29/u...s-own-death.html?_r=1&partner=rss&emc=rss

Michael Jackson probably caused his own death, witness testifies
Doctor supports Conrad Murray's defense team, saying the star probably injected himself with fatal dose of propofol.
By Victoria Kim and Harriet Ryan, Los Angeles Times
October 29, 2011

A leading anesthesiologist told jurors Friday in the trial of Michael Jackson's personal physician that the singer probably caused his own death by injecting himself with a dose of the drug while his doctor wasn't looking.

In his testimony, defense expert Paul White directly challenged the theory put forth by the government's main medical witness, Dr. Steven Shafer. The prosecution expert testified that the only plausible scenario was that Dr. Conrad Murray had left a large intravenous drip of the anesthetic propofol running into the singer's bloodstream for three hours, even after Jackson had stopped breathing.

On Friday, White said Shafer's theory was ruled out by the level of the drug found in Jackson's urine at autopsy. Given the urine levels and evidence at the scene, the more likely explanation was that the singer gave himself the drug, said White, one of the first U.S. researchers to study the drug.
"You think it was self-injection of propofol ... between 11:30 and 12 o'clock?" defense attorney Michael Flanagan asked.
"In my opinion, yes," White said.

White's statement is the first evidence the defense has put forward to support a theory they've argued all along: that it was Jackson, not Murray, who administered the dose of propofol that killed the pop star. Shafer testified that blood levels of the drug found at autopsy did not support self-injection, and he called that a "crazy scenario."

White offered no defense to what several medical experts called by prosecutors have told jurors — that even if Jackson gave himself the drug, Murray was still responsible for the singer's death for leaving him unattended. At the beginning of his testimony Thursday, he acknowledged that he could not explain away Murray's conduct.
The concession suggested that Murray's defense planned on admitting that the doctor made missteps but denying that he directly caused his famous patient's death.

The anesthesiologist's testimony also supported a second defense contention: that the singer swallowed several tablets of the sedative lorazepam. That drug, combined with the propofol they say Jackson gave himself, caused a "perfect storm" that killed the star instantly, they have told jurors.

"The fact that there is even a tiny amount of free lorazepam [in Jackson's stomach] is consistent with the theory that he took lorazepam orally," White said.
Flanagan asked if the drugs Murray admitted to giving Jackson in his police interview — small injections of two sedatives followed by a half dose of propofol — could have caused the singer's death.
"Would this present a dangerous situation here?" the attorney asked.
"Not at all," White said.

White, the final defense witness, is expected to resume his testimony Monday at the downtown Los Angeles courthouse and will be cross-examined by a prosecutor. Murray, 58, faces up to four years in prison if convicted of the involuntary manslaughter charge; he has pleaded not guilty.

victoria.kim@latimes.com
harriet.ryan@latimes.com
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-conrad-murray-20111029,0,4175915.story?track=rss


Michael Jackson gave himself fatal overdose, expert says
By Alan Duke, CNN
October 28, 2011 -- Updated 2123 GMT (0523 HKT)

Los Angeles (CNN) -- Michael Jackson probably died after he rapidly injected himself with a dose of the surgical anesthetic propofol on top of a large dose of sedatives he swallowed when Dr. Conrad Murray was away, the defense's propofol expert testified Friday.

The prosecution theory of how Jackson died requires "an incredible coincidence of circumstances" using a "befuddling" IV drip configuration and an "irrational" assumption about how Murray injected sedatives, Dr. Paul White testified.
White, the last defense witness in Murray's involuntary manslaughter trial, challenged the assumptions used by prosecution anesthesia expert Dr. Steven Shafer to conclude that Jackson's death was caused by an infusion of the surgical anesthetic propofol set up by Murray.

Deputy district attorney David Walgren will take the weekend to confer with Shafer before beginning his cross-examination of White on Monday morning.

Closing arguments could be heard as soon as Tuesday in the trial that started a month ago, depending on how long the prosecution takes with its questioning of White and if it chooses to recall Shafer in rebuttal.

The defense theory is that a desperate Jackson, fearing that his comeback concerts could be canceled unless he found elusive sleep, self-administered propofol that Murray was trying to wean him off of. It contends that Jackson also swallowed eight lorazepam tablets while Murray was not watching.

Shafer conceded last week that it was possible that Jackson, not Murray, could have been the one to open the IV drip to a fatal pace, but prosecutors contend that it would make no difference in Murray's guilt.
Murray is responsible for Jackson's death even if he did not give him the final and fatal dose, because he was criminally reckless in using the surgical anesthetic to help Jackson sleep without proper precautions, the prosecution contends.

White testified Friday that it is his opinion Jackson died after he injected himself with a 25-milligram dose of propofol between 11:30 a.m. and noon June 25, 2009.
Testimony and phone records indicated it was about noon that Murray realized Jackson was not breathing.

White theorized that Jackson could have "pushed" the drug into an catheter in his leg using a syringe over a 15- to 30-second period, much faster than a doctor would have done.
"I believe it could potentially have lethal consequences," White testified.
White also concluded that Jackson swallowed a large dose of lorazepam several hours earlier, which would have left "a very high concentration" of the sedative in his body. "So you've got drugs that have additive or even synergistic effects, and I think the combination effect would be very profound," White said.

Shafer, who testified over an 11-day span for the prosecution, concluded the "only scenario" that fits the scientific evidence -- mainly the drug levels found in Jackson's blood after his death -- is that Jackson was on an IV drip of propofol for three hours before his death.
White, however, testified Friday that with such a flow of propofol, Jackson would have been "sleepy but arousable but breathing spontaneously." It would not have killed him, he said.

The 100-milliliter propofol bottle prosecutors believe Murray used was empty when investigators found it, leading Shafer to conclude that the last drops entered Jackson's body just as his heart stopped beating.
White called it "an incredible coincidence of circumstances" that the bottle would empty exactly when Jackson died.

The defense expert also questioned the prosecution contention that Murray placed the propofol bottle into an empty saline bag with an opening cut into it to suspend it from the IV stand next to Jackson's bed.
It would have been more logical for Murray to use a plastic suspension tab built onto the bottle, a routine practice.
"It's befuddling to me, because anyone picking up the bottle would naturally gravitate for pulling up the little hanger," White said. "Why would you go to all the hassle?"
Hanging the bottle inside a bag also would not work because if Jackson "rolled over and moved his leg, it would easily come out of the bag," White said.
The suspension tab on the propofol bottle had not been activated, both sides agreed.
Investigators who recovered the bottle and an opened bag testified they found them together, but they did not photograph it.

White also questioned Shafer's computer model conclusion that Murray gave Jackson at least nine four-milligram injections of the sedative lorazepam at regular intervals from 1:30 to 5 a.m. the day he died.
Those "enormous" sedative doses alone would have put anyone to sleep and possibly killed them, White said.
He said it would be "irrational" for a doctor to sit at Jackson's bedside and repeatedly injected the sedatives to a patient in very deep sedation, as Shafer's theory implies.

Friday's court session, which lasted only three hours, was attended by Michael Jackson's father, Joe, sister Janet and brother Randy. Brother Jermaine Jackson's daughter, Autumn, and Randy's son, Randy Jackson Jr., also sat in court. Kathy Hilton, who was a childhood friend of Michael Jackson's, and her husband, Rick Hilton were also in court Friday.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/10/28/j...d-murray-trial/index.html?eref=rss_topstories
 
Last edited:
Witness says Jackson doctor's actions can't be justified
The defense questioning of its expert, a propofol researcher, suggests lawyers will concede that Dr. Conrad Murray's care was substandard but argue that it did not constitute involuntary manslaughter.

By Harriet Ryan and Victoria Kim, Los Angeles Times
October 28, 2011

The star medical expert for Michael Jackson's physician began his testimony Thursday with the acknowledgment that not even he could explain the doctor's treatment of the pop star.

"Let's deal with the elephant in the room here," a defense attorney said to Dr. Paul White, the most important and probably final witness for the physician. "Conrad Murray has been accused of infusing a dose of propofol and leaving his patient. Can you justify that?"
"Absolutely not," White replied.

The exchange was a strong indication the defense planned to concede that Murray provided substandard care to Jackson but argue that his conduct did not rise to the level of involuntary manslaughter.

Exactly how White would advance the defense case was unclear in his initial two hours of testimony, a period he spent mostly laying out his academic credentials and familiarity with propofol. Some of his responses suggested he would provide a counter-theory to the damaging conclusions of the prosecution's central expert witness, White's longtime friend and fellow anesthesiology researcher Steven Shafer.

In five days of testimony ending this week, Shafer told jurors the singer died from a massive intravenous dose of propofol that an inattentive Murray allowed to continue even after Jackson stopped breathing.

In his testimony, White said there were problems with the math models Shafer presented to bolster his claims. Those graphs, White said, might show how the general population would respond to a drug, but "the challenge is using models to predict levels in a specific or particular individual."
White also seemed to offer some support for Murray's use of propofol for Jackson's insomnia, something three prosecution experts have condemned. He said off-label drug use by physicians is common and legal and described a recent Chinese study of propofol as an insomnia treatment as flawed but "very interesting." Shafer had rejected the same study.

The stakes of the two experts' testimony became apparent last week when White was accused of calling Shafer, who had criticized his analysis, a "scumbag." White denied the allegation, but the judge set a November hearing for possible contempt-of-court charges.

Shafer was not present for his colleague's testimony, but he was mentioned so frequently that the judge and a defense attorney repeatedly referred to White by Shafer's name.
"I should get a name tag," White joked.
White was one of the first American researchers to test propofol, and his clinical trials in the 1980s paved the way for the drug's FDA approval. He told jurors that when the defense approached him earlier this year, he was hesitant.
"I really wasn't sure I wanted to get involved in a high-profile celebrity case involving the death of an icon," White said.
Before White took the stand, an addiction specialist testified that Jackson was "probably" addicted to Demerol provided by his dermatologist.

Dr. Robert Waldman, who works at a Malibu rehabilitation center, said medical records indicated that the dermatologist, Arnold Klein, injected the singer with increasingly large doses of the painkiller during office visits for Botox and another wrinkle remover.
"I believe there's evidence he was dependent on Demerol," Waldman said.
He said that factoring in "what's known about his public behavior" -- a reference, he said later, to media reports about the singer's past drug problems -- Jackson "was probably addicted to opioids."
The defense has sought to blame Klein for Jackson's insomnia. Withdrawal from the painkiller left him unable to sleep at a time when he needed rest for critical rehearsals and drove him to self-administer propofol, Murray's lawyers have said.

Waldman said he believed the cosmetic procedures Klein provided Jackson would not cause severe pain that necessitated Demerol. Jackson received as much as 375 milligrams of Demerol in a 90-minute period, Klein's records show. A typical dose is 50 milligrams, Waldman said.

On cross-examination, a prosecutor implied that Waldman's testimony was irrelevant to the manslaughter case before the jury. "You understand there is no Demerol in the toxicology findings" from Jackson's autopsy, said Deputy Dist. Atty. David Walgren.
"Correct," Waldman replied.

The case is expected to go to the jury next week. If convicted, Murray, 58, faces a maximum of four years in prison.

harriet.ryan@latimes.com victoria.kim@latimes.com
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/l...mostviewed+(L.A.+Times+-+Most+Viewed+Stories)


Defense likely to rest
11:00 PM, Oct. 27, 2011

LOS ANGELES — Testimony for the defense in the involuntary manslaughter trial of Michael Jackson's personal doctor could wrap up as early as today.

The defense of cardiologist Conrad Murray entered its fifth day Thursday. Dr. Paul White, an anesthesiologist and a noted researcher on the surgical anesthetic that caused Jackson's death, took the stand as Murray's 16th and last announced witness. Jackson died at his home at age 50 on June 25, 2009. Prosecutors say Murray negligently administered an overdose of propofol and a sedative, criminally violating medical standards by using propofol to treat Jackson's insomnia. The prosecution focused on Murray's actions during his two months of treating Jackson. The state presented four doctors who said Murray "egregiously" breached ethical guidelines.

The defense, led by Houston lawyer Ed Chernoff, shifted the focus to Jackson. "Our main defense," Chernoff told Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor on Tuesday, "is that Michael Jackson took action with his own hand out of a desperate desire to get to sleep." Murray's team contends that Jackson self-administered propofol and swallowed eight tablets of the sedative lorazepam while Murray was away from the pop star's bedroom.

Murray's lawyers placed nearly equal blame on Arnold Klein of Beverly Hills, Jackson's longtime dermatologist. The defense says Klein caused Jackson's insomnia. Dr. Robert Waldman, a Los Angeles addiction specialist, used Klein's medical records and what Waldman termed Jackson's "public behavior" since the 1980s as the basis for his testimony that Jackson "probably was addicted" to the painkiller Demerol after large repeated injections by Klein. A side effect of withdrawal from Demerol is insomnia, Waldman said.

White, who continues testifying today, was retained to counter anesthesiology expert Steven Shafer on propofol's effects. Shafer spent more than four days testifying that the likely means of Jackson's death was a steady, three-hour intravenous drip of 1,000 micrograms of propofol by an inattentive Murray. Chernoff said in his opening statement to jurors on Sept. 27 that White will prove that Murray could not have administered the fatal dose of propofol. Two other health care professionals gave testimony supporting defense arguments that Jackson could have been so addicted to propofol and so desperate to get it that he accidentally killed himself.

The defense has suffered some setbacks. Pastor blocked defense attempts to argue that financial desperation motivated Jackson's self-dosing. And toxicology evidence showed a tiny amount of lorazepam in Jackson's stomach at autopsy, damaging defense arguments that swallowing lorazepam contributed to the death.
http://www.mjjcommunity.com/forum/t...-reports-articles-Merged-No-discussion/page17
 
Last edited:
abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Exclusive tidbits: there was an issue between the attorneys behind the scene that had to do with the subpoena of Dr #Murray's certification

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
More: Defense attorneys subpoenaed hospital for Dr Murray's certification on sedation and doc was delivered to atty's office, not the court

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Chernoff told judge that he has an issue with the document now but didn't have 6 weeks ago when he received a copy of it.

» abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Chernoff: if (Walgren) had a concern with the certification document he should've said something earlier. This is just, frankly, a ploy.

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Walgren said he received doc some weeks ago and was not disputing whatever representation it was making. Judge allow them in for fairness.

30 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply »
abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge asked attys what 2 tell jurors that was truthful yet innocuous (about trial ending early 2day) Flanagan: have nice lunch, nice weekend

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Walgren said he would prefer it not appeared to fall on him. Judge decided to say it's agreed by parties & court and be the "bad guy" again

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Just to clarify: Chernoff told judge that Walgren received the cert document 6 weeks ago and Walgren didn't have an issue w/ it until now

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Walgren was having an issue with the certification document. He claimed the process by which it was delivered 2 him violated the court rules

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge admonished attorneys that he expects attorneys to be in communication over the weekend and cannot have continuing issues w/ discovery.

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge: (there is) seemingly no end 2 the case when it comes to the defense and potential rebuttal, potential surrebutal. I need 2 move this!

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge told attorneys they need 2 be looking at the jury instructions he provided, involuntary manslaughter instructions, issues of causation

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Chernoff told the judge he has never experienced anything like the jury charges he's seeing. He says it's very detailed and specific.

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Chernoff says that in Texas the jury charges (I think he means jury instructions) is 2 pages. #conradmurraytrial

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge to attorneys: be aware of the jurors, we're now past the date. I don't want major surprises anymore.

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Prosecutor David Walgren told the judge he will probably take all day on Monday cross examining Dr. Paul White. #conradmurraytrial
18 hours ago Favorite Retweet Reply
 
Last edited:
October 28, 2011
Judge: Trial is taking too long
Posted: 02:47 PM ET

The judge apologized to jurors Friday for delays in the trial before releasing them for the weekend.

"We are past the date I told you your services would be over," Judge Michael Pastor said. "But I know all of you understand that things happen in cases... I recognize the sacrifices you're making. So please continue to hang in there and enjoy your weekend."

During a chambers meeting with lawyers on Thursday, prosecutor David Walgren asked the judge for more time to consider new evidence submitted by the defense. The evidence includes new simulations from defense expert Dr. Paul White, which show the possible effects of the drugs that were in Michael Jackson's system the day he died.
Walgren called the graphs of the new simulations, "hieroglyphics."

Judge Pastor acknowledged Walgren's concerns, but said he's worried about changing the schedule because the jurors have lives and commitments outside of the trial. Walgren said that losing jurors to scheduling conflicts is a risk the state is prepared to take.
Judge Pastor granted the state to begin their cross examination of Dr. White on Monday, giving them the weekend to examine the new defense evidence.

Once Dr. White's testimony is concluded, we expect that the defense will rest. After the defense rests, the prosecution will likely present some sort of rebuttal case.
If things go more quickly than anticipated, closings in the trial could still be Monday. That scenario, however, now seems remote.

If testimony continues into or concludes on Monday – which is certainly possible – then closings in the case could be Tuesday.
But it's also possible that Tuesday could be a dark day, to give the attorneys time to prepare their closing arguments. If that happens, then closings would be delivered on Wednesday.

Posted by: In Session's Graham Winch
http://insession.blogs.cnn.com/2011/10/28/judge-trial-is-taking-too-long/
 
Conrad Murray trial: Jackson jury is drip fed evidence as finale nears
As the trial of Michael Jackson's doctor Conrad Murray enters its final days, Nick Allen looks at the circus surrounding the much-hyped trial.
By Nick Allen, Los Angeles
7:00PM BST 29 Oct 2011

Arriving at a restaurant a short stroll from the Pacific Ocean this week, Dr Conrad Murray was generous in his assesmment of those attempting to prove he is a killer.
Before heading to a table with his actress girlfriend Nicole Alvarez, 29, and their two-year-old son, he said: "I would like to pray for the prosecutor, his associates, and his expert witness. I pray for them. That's all I can say."

The 58-year-old physician to the late Michael Jackson is barred from talking about the intricacies of his case, but it is clear there is much he would like to say about the way he has been portrayed as greedy, starstruck, incompetent and medically reckless.
Within a matter of days a jury will decide whether it was indeed his negligence that led to the singer's death, or if he was simply in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Each morning, Dr Murray makes the 20 mile trip from his rented apartment in the seaside town of Santa Monica to the Clara Shortridge Foltz criminal justice centre, a monolithic concrete tower block in the heart of downtown Los Angeles.
He enters through a back door to avoid running a gauntlet of hatred out front, where his detractors wave placards bearing slogans such as "Lock up the Doc" in front of TV cameras.
Once inside he sits at a table with his legal team and from 8.45am a television camera is trained permanently on his face, broadcasting his reactions live to millions across America.
On the advice of his lawyers Dr Murray, who denies a charge of involuntary manslaughter, has tried to maintain an impassive mask.
But every time it slips, with a furrow of the brow or a moistening of the eyes, the moment is endlessly replayed and dissected by high profile legal analysts on TV.
So far their verdict is that things have not gone well for the defendant.

The prosecution has, in the opinion of most commentators, had a field day.
Over a period of four weeks David Walgren, a dogged Los Angeles deputy district attorney, has sought to prove that Dr Murray gave his insomniac patient an overdoese of propofol, a powerful anaesthetic intended for use in hospitals, and then failed to call 9-11 when he stopped breathing.
Jackson, who was rehearsing for a major series of concerts in London, was found dead at the age of 50 in his rented mansion in Los Angeles on June 25, 2009.
Dr Murray has admitted giving the singer a small amount, 25mg, of the drug.

The defence case rests on the theory that Jackson self-administered another, lethal dose while his doctor was out of the room, and that the entertainer therefore caused his own death.

The early headline moments from the trial came when Mr Walgren controversially presented a harrowing photograph of Jackson lying dead on a gurney, and a haunting tape of him slurring while apparently heavily sedated. With a dramatic flourish he also produced an IV bag and propofol bottle.
But the real damage to Dr Murray was done subsequently by a less theatrical, but steady, drip-feed of medical evidence.

The prosecution's star witness was an unassuming, white-haired anaesthesiologist called Dr Steven Shafer, who methodically set about demolishing Dr Murray's reputation.
It was he who wrote the guidelines and warnings that accompany each vial of propofol. In court he detailed a total of 17 "egregious" violations of the standard of care committed by Dr Murray, any one of which could have led to a "catastrophic outcome."
He also accused Dr Murray of operating in a "pharmacological never-never land" and even set up an IV drip in the court room to show how Jackson's $150,000-a-month personal physician had done it wrong.

In an attempt to undermine Dr Shafer's damning critique, which took up a week in the witness box, the defence produced their own expert, a man known to his peers as "the father of propofol."
The appearance of Dr Paul White set off an academic sub plot when it emerged that he and Dr Shafer had been friends and colleagues since meeting at Stanford University in 1978.
Their relationship appeared to have soured as a result of the trial, Dr White telling a journalist: "I will take the high road, not the low road with him." It earned him a post-trial hearing for possible contempt of court from Judge Michael Pastor, who has gagged trial participants from talking to the media.

Dr White was also accused of whispering "scumbag" to journalists during his former colleague's evidence., although he denies doing so.
The 16th and final person to take the stand on Dr Murray's behalf, Dr White used a complicated mathematical model to show that Jackson had probably injected hinmself with 25mg of propofol about one hour after a similar dose was administered by Dr Murray.
He said the second, self-injected dose of propofol, combined with eight tablets of the sedative lorazepam taken earlier in the night, could have had "lethal consequences."

The defence case is already drawing to a close after just one week, amid rumours of a rift between members of Dr Murray's defence team.
His lead attorney, the cigar-chewing Texas-based Ed Chernoff, had been staying at the California home of defence lawyer J Michael Flanagan, but has reportedly moved out.

In an attempt to highlight their client's skills as a doctor the defence called a string of former patients whose hearts Dr Murray had repaired with stents and other procedures.
Andrew Guest of Las Vegas told the court: "I'm alive today because of that man. That man sitting there is the best doctor I've ever seen."
Another patient, Ruby Mosley, described how Dr Murray founded a clinic in a poor Houston neighborhood in memory of his father. At that point tears welled up in the eyes of the normally stoic-looking defendant.

Dr Murray also has supporters outside court, amid the circus that accompanies anything to do with Michael Jackson, even in death.
Beatrice Fakhrian, a film and television agent, stands on the pavement every day brandishing a sign saying "Fair Trial for Dr Murray."
She told The Sunday Telegraph: "He's a gentle giant, very sofly spoken, non-threatening, non-confrontational. We played golf together recently and he's a member of my church. He's a very Christian, godly man who is very generous to people in need. He loved Michael Jackson. They were friends."

Standing just three yards away, eyeing Miss Fakhrian warily, stands Jackson fan Denise Smith, 47, a machinist from Seattle who is convinced of the doctor's guilt.
She said: "I think the prosecution has proved it's case and defence is a waste of time. Dr Murray is too chicken to get on the stand and answer the questions from the prosecution."
At the outset of the trial the rival camps used to form prayer circles, but as the weeks have gone by tempers have flared. Occasionally police have had to come in to keep the peace.

Among Jackson fans conspiracy theories are rife. Denis Conruit, 41, who came from Paris, France with a sign saying "Justice Pour Michael," said: "We want to discover the conspiracy behind the trial because Murray is the perfect scapegoat. There are lots of other people behind this."
Among the wilder theories are that Jackson was murdered by shadowy figures who wanted to make money out of his death. His own sister La Toya claims the singer told her he was going to be killed, and alleges that someone else was with Jackson and Dr Murray in the room when he died.

There has been no sign yet that Dr Murray himself will take the witness stand, and legal analysts said doing so could backfire. So far the jury of seven men and five women has only heard him speak in a recording of a two hour interview with police, in which the doctor said he had been trying to wean Jackson off propofol.

If convicted he faces up to four years in prison but, even if he received the maximum sentence, he might serve little or no time in jail due to overcrowding.
As a non-violent offender he may well be placed under house arrest and be required to wear an electronic tag.
"That's ridiculous," complained Jackson fan Miss Smith outside court.
"But what we want is for him to lose his medical licence, that's the main thing."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/...ury-is-drip-fed-evidence-as-finale-nears.html


Jury to decide fate of accused Jackson doctor

AFP Sunday, Oct 30, 2011
LOS ANGELES - The trial of Michael Jackson's doctor Conrad Murray enters its final act this week, as a jury prepares to consider whether the medic is guilty over the King of Pop's death in 2009.

After five weeks of testimony, some 40 witnesses and dizzying hours of medical argument, the seven male and five female jurors will finally be given the task of deciding the 58-year-old doctor's fate.
While many observers find it difficult to see how Murray can escape a guilty verdict, after four weeks of relentless prosecution testimony, the defense will hope to make a final appeal to sway the decision its way.

On Monday, prosecutors will grill the last witness, renowned anesthesiologist Dr. Paul White, who on Friday backed the defense theory that Jackson caused his own death by taking extra doses of sedative without Murray's knowledge.
Prosecutor David Walgren and chief defense counsel Ed Chernoff will then present their closing arguments, before judge Michael Pastor asks the jury to retire to consider its verdict.
Murray faces up to four years in jail if convicted of involuntary manslaughter over Jackson's from "acute propofol intoxication" on June 25, 2009 in Los Angeles, where he was rehearsing for a series of planned comeback shows.

The prosecution claims Murray, who was being paid $150,000 a month to look after Jackson, killed the King of Pop by administering a deadly cocktail of drugs to help him sleep, and then abandoning him at the crucial moment.

The defense has sought to present Jackson as a desperate drug addict, who would have ended up killing himself with an accidental overdose with or without Murray's help.

But Murray's case was not helped by his own account of Jackson's final hours, given to police in an interview two days after his death, and played back in court early on in the trial.
In the gripping recording, he explained blow-by-blow how he tried in vain to help Jackson sleep from the early hours of the day he died, giving him a series of drugs including lorazepam and midazolam by intravenous (IV) injection.
He had been giving Jackson propofol - a clinic anesthetic not usually used outside of a hospital setting - nightly for two months to help him sleep, but began weaning him off of the drug three days before his death.
At 10:40 am on the fateful day he said he gave the star 25 mg of the drug - which Jackson begged for, calling it his "milk" - as a last-ditch way to finally get him to sleep.
Murray claimed he only left the star for two minutes to go to the bathroom, and returned to find Jackson not breathing.
The trouble is, the timeline and phone records raised a number of questions: Murray was on the phone to a series of girlfriends when Jackson was apparently dying, while the doctor delayed calling 911 for an agonizingly long time.

To counter the questions, the defense over the last week of the trial presented two key witnesses, Dr Allan Metzger and nurse Cherilyn Lee, who testified how Jackson had begged for propofol months before his death.
Jackson was desperate to sleep, as he prepared for the "This is It" series of 50 comeback concerts in London.

Another key witness, addiction expert Dr. Robert Waldman, said Jackson's chronic insomnia could well be due to withdrawal from painkiller Demerol, given to him several times a week by a Beverly Hills dermatologist, Dr. Arnold Klein.

The end of the trial boiled down to a clash between two renowned experts on propofol: Dr. White for the defense, and Dr. Steven Shafer - coincidentally a former junior colleague of Dr. White - for the prosecution.
White, who will take the stand for the last time Monday, summed up the defense's case - that Jackson effectively killed himself - on Friday.
"So you think it was self-injection of propofol .. between 11:30 and 12 o'clock that did it?" Murray's defense attorney Michael Flanagan asked White, after complex testimony about what exactly Jackson could have taken and when.
"In my opinion, yes," said the respected anesthesiologist.

The coming week will see whether the jury agrees.
http://www.asiaone.com/News/Latest+News/Showbiz/Story/A1Story20111030-307735.html
 
Last edited:
<SCRIPT type=text/javascript>Drupal.DART.tag('atf', '660x88', {"dtid":"7","obj":{"dtid":"7","active":"1","name":"660x88 tile=10 (articles page)","pos":"atf","sz":"660x88","block":"0","settings":{"options":{"scriptless":0,"keyvals":"tile|10","method":"adj","terms":1},"site":"","zone":"","slug":"","rules":{"domains":null,"paths":"all_paths","node_types":{"photos":"photos","giveaway":"giveaway","image_ad":"image_ad","multichoice":"multichoice","simplenews":"simplenews","other_sites_we_like":"other_sites_we_like","other_stories_we_like":"other_stories_we_like","page":"page","quiz":"quiz","story":"story","ticker":"ticker","webform":"webform","stories_we_like":0},"taxonomy":{"3":"","5":"","2":"","4":""}}}},"active":"1","name":"660x88 tile=10 (articles page)","pos":"atf","sz":"660x88","site":"radar.other","zone":"","slug":"","options":{"scriptless":0,"keyvals":{"dcopt":[{"val":"isttile","eval":false},{"val":"ist","eval":false}],"aid":[{"val":"53832","eval":false}],"kw":[{"val":"beagles","eval":false},{"val":"celebrity_justice","eval":false},{"val":"david_walgren","eval":false},{"val":"dr._conrad_murray","eval":false},{"val":"dr._paul_white","eval":false},{"val":"exclusive","eval":false},{"val":"michael_jackson","eval":false},{"val":"peta","eval":false},{"val":"propofol","eval":false},{"val":"trial","eval":false}],"tile":[{"val":"10","eval":false}]},"method":"adj","terms":1,"block":null},"rules":{"domains":null,"paths":"all_paths","node_types":{"photos":"photos","giveaway":"giveaway","image_ad":"image_ad","multichoice":"multichoice","simplenews":"simplenews","other_sites_we_like":"other_sites_we_like","other_stories_we_like":"other_stories_we_like","page":"page","quiz":"quiz","story":"story","ticker":"ticker","webform":"webform","stories_we_like":0},"taxonomy":{"3":"","5":"","2":"","4":""},"user_roles":{"1":0,"2":0,"5":0,"3":0,"4":0}},"prefix":"ami"});</SCRIPT><SCRIPT type=text/javascript src="http://ad.doubleclick.net/adj/ami.radar.other/;pos=atf;sz=660x88;dcopt=ist;aid=53832;kw=beagles,celebrity_justice,david_walgren,dr._conrad_murray,dr._paul_white,exclusive,michael_jackson,peta,propofol,trial;tile=10;ord=1342349235?"></SCRIPT> <NOSCRIPT></NOSCRIPT>
Dr. Conrad Murray Will Not Testify In Michael Jackson Death Trial



Posted on Oct 31, 2011 @ 06:29AM
WENN

By Jen Heger,
Radar Legal Editor
Dr. Conrad Murray will not be taking the witness stand to testify in his defense in the Michael Jackson death trial, RadarOnline.com is exclusively reporting.
Dr. Murray has been charged with involuntary manslaughter in connection with the King of Pop's death. Testimony will resume Monday with the defense's final witness, Dr. Paul White. Deputy District Attorney David Walgren will be cross examining the propofol expert.
"Dr. Murray has told his lawyers from day one that he wants to testify, and tell his side of events. But lead attorney Ed Chernoff has determined that Dr. Murray will not take the stand because he wouldn't be able to withstand the tough cross examination that the DA would subject him to," a source close to Dr. Murray tells RadarOnline.com.

"Clients always want to testify, but in this case, Walgren would be able to wear him down, and Dr. Murray just wouldn't be able to overcome the basic facts of the case: not calling 911 right away, failure to tell emergency room doctors and first responders that he had given Jackson propofol, and not having the proper monitoring equipment," the source adds.
After the defense formally rests their case, the District Attorney could call several witnesses for rebuttal. "No decision has been made yet if Walgren will be putting on a rebuttal case," a law enforcement insider tells RadarOnline.com.
Dr. White admitted under questioning from one of Murray's lawyers to giving Propofol orally to 'animals.'

As RadarOnline.com previously reported, Dr. Conrad Murray's defense team commissioned a study on Beagle dogs to determine how much of the drug would have to be orally ingested to cause Jackson's death. The defense was forced to abandon that theory after tests proved it would be impossible for someone to die from orally ingesting Propofol.
PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals), filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) alleging "cruel drug toxicity tests on beagles commissioned by the defense team of Dr. Conrad Murray, the physician now on trial for his alleged role in Michael Jackson's death.
Read PETA's Letter To The USDA
“PETA asserts that if attorneys from Flanagan, Unger, Grover & McCool did commission the tests for the drug Propofol - the toxic effects of which have been extensively studied in dogs and humans - those tests were likely conducted in violation of the federal Animal Welfare Act's prohibition against tests on animals that duplicate previous experiments. PETA has filed a complaint with the State Bar of California as well,"the organization said in their complaint."
Read PETA's Complaint To The California Bar
If convicted of the involuntary manslaughter charge, Murray could face up to four years in state prison.

http://www.radaronline.com/exclusives/2011/10/conrad-murray-not-testify-michael-jackson-death-trial
 

Professors' views on Jackson death create rift

By Joyce Lupiani
CREATED 3:05 AM

.sidebar .video-player { display: none; }.sidebar .video-related { display: none; }Los Angeles, CA (AP) -- A prosecutor will get his chance to grill a defense expert who told jurors last week that he believes Michael Jackson gave himself a fatal dose of a powerful anesthetic.
Dr. Paul White is likely to face tough questions from a prosecutor who was granted extra time to prepare for Monday's trial session.
White is testifying for Dr. Conrad Murray, who has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter.
The retired anesthesiologist and research told jurors that he concluded that Jackson must have given himself a fatal dose of the anesthetic propofol, which Murray was giving him as a sleep aid. White says it is the only explanation that fits all the evidence in the case, although another prominent expert has called White's theory "crazy."
http://www.ktnv.com/news/local/132907223.html
 

Ghost of Jackson, “Mr. Lorazepam,” hangs over trial

LOS ANGELES: At times the wood-lined courtroom could have passed for a medical lecture theater: experts with saline drip stands and complicated graphs earnestly demonstrating the half-life of benzodiazepines.

Except that you don’t usually see Janet and LaToya Jackson sitting in the back of a pharmacology class, listening attentively to explanations of sedation thresholds and titration techniques.

But this has been the scene in the plainly furnished room on the ninth floor of the LA Superior Court in downtown Los Angeles, where Michael Jackson’s doctor Conrad Murray has been on trial for the last five weeks.

Jackson – who in one of the more surreal moments of the trial was inadvertently refered to as “Mr. Lorazepam” – has been the spectre hanging over proceedings which come to a climax this week.

“Let’s deal with the elephant in the room here,” defense attorney Michael Flanagan intoned last Thursday. “Conrad Murray has been accused of infusing a dose of propofol and leaving his patient. Can you justify that?”

His star witness, Dr Paul White, couldn’t. But that was what he was here for, to debunk the prosecution claim that Grenada-born medic Murray was guilty of involuntary manslaughter over the King of Pop’s 2009 death.

Murray – who has sat grim-faced throughout the sometimes harrowing, sometimes eye-glazingly dull testimony – denies the charge.

His iPad-wielding lawyers Ed Chernoff and lugubrious sidekick Flanagan have done their best to defy the odds and get him off, arguing that Jackson was a desperate addict who would have killed himself accidentally anyway.

They have been helped by a spectacular litany of medical problems from which Jackson apparently suffered for years before his untimely death on June 25, 2009, on the eve of an ill-fated series of comeback shows in London.

Incontinence, insomnia and mental instability were just three revealed in painful detail at the trial, which heard how Jackson died from a cocktail of the sedatives lorazepam, midazolam and propofol, given to help him sleep.

A condom catheter, intravenous (IV) drug tube and oxygen nasal canulla were attached to Jackson’s body when paramedics arrived, while pictures of his naked corpse on a hospital gurney had his family running from the courtroom.

Led by his mother Katherine and father Joe, the family has filed in every day since September 27, some members more often than others – to sit on the wooden benches reserved for them at the front of the court’s public seating.

Occasionally, they would turn to exchange words with journalists sat behind them, while Jackson fans – winners of a daily ballot for tickets for the handful of spare seats in court – were consigned to the back row.

Genial judge Michael Pastor has drawn praise, sharing jokes with the jurors and court staff – but he is not to be crossed: when a fan’s phone went off near the trial’s start, she was escorted smartly out, the device confiscated.

Early witnesses included a cocktail waitress and a quintessentially Hollywood actress, Murray’s girlfriend – who couldn’t contain her breathless excitement at having met Michael Jackson, even as she discussed his death.

A string of friendly character witnesses came on proclaiming how the “caring” Murray saved their lives and treated them for free – prompting the 58-year-old medic to dab his eyes at one stage.

But the last week descended into a dizzying blizzard of medical testimony, as key witnesses argued over exactly what Murray might have done, or not done, in the fateful hours before Jackson’s death.

Murray’s lawyers, and even the judge seemed to tire at the end, repeatedly confusing the names of the two sides’ opposing propofol experts, one of whom allegedly called the other a “scumbag” in the back of the court.

Flanagan it was who seemed to have most problems concentrating – drawing laughter when, in the middle of another interminable exchange Friday, he called Jackson “Mr. Lorazepam” – and didn’t notice until the judge pointed it out.

Jackson, dubbed various things during his life, including most famously the King of Pop, was clearly a keen student of pharmaceuticals. But some suspect even he would turn in his grave at that new name.

http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/31/ghost-of-jackson-mr-lorazepam-hangs-over-trial.html
 
Experts’ conflicting conclusions in Jackson doctor case create tension, choice for jury
By Associated Press, Updated: Monday, October 31, 7:56 AM


<!-- /byline --><ARTICLE>LOS ANGELES — The differing opinions of two professors on how a powerful anesthetic killed Michael Jackson has left jurors with two scenarios to consider about how the King of Pop died, and in the process has also strained the relationship of the two longtime collaborators and friends.

Armed with decades of experience, IV bags and syringes, the men showed jurors how a powerful, milky-white anesthetic may have flowed from a bottle into Jackson’s body on the morning of June 25, 2009
<IMG style="POSITION: absolute; FILTER: alpha(opacity=0)"><IMG style="POSITION: absolute; FILTER: alpha(opacity=0)"><IMG style="POSITION: absolute; FILTER: alpha(opacity=0)"><IMG style="POSITION: absolute; FILTER: alpha(opacity=0)"><IMG style="POSITION: absolute; FILTER: alpha(opacity=0)">
<!--INLINE_BB AD BEGIN-->Doctors Paul White and Steven Shafer worked alongside each other for years and are credited with helping bring propofol to operating rooms and making its usage safe.

But their different theories on how Jackson died from the drug — whether his personal physician Conrad Murray administered it or the singer injected it himself — have sparked a clash of harsh rhetoric between the two men more familiar with operating rooms and classrooms than the high stakes of a celebrity trial.

White and Shafer were colleagues at Stanford University and conducted research on propofol before it was approved for use in U.S. operating rooms in 1989. Both help edit a leading anesthesia journal. Until White’s retirement last year, both were practicing anesthesiologists.
Each man’s search to explain how Jackson died led them to conduct their own research and computer modeling.

The tension between them began after Shafer, an affable Columbia University researcher, told jurors on Oct. 20 that he was “disappointed” in White for suggesting earlier that Jackson may have drunk the fatal dose of propofol.

Shafer’s dismissive comment that even first-year medical students knew that wouldn’t work cut deeply for White, who worked on propofol for six years before it was approved for use in the United States.

As Shafer testified, White occasionally shook his head until being admonished by a judge to stop making any gestures in court.

White, according to a report posted online by E! Entertainment Television, turned to reporters while Shafer testified and called either Shafer or a prosecutor a “scumbag.” White later told a judge he didn’t recall making the remark but acknowledged talking to an E! reporter about being bothered by Shafer’s testimony.

“Of course, when someone makes derogatory comments about you in court, it has an effect on you,” White told the judge. “I was very disappointed in Dr. Shafer’s remark.”

White’s interview may earn him a contempt-of-court violation for violating a gag order, but that issue will be decided after Murray’s trial is concluded.

The courtroom rhetoric between the men cooled last week, with White repeatedly crediting Shafer for his work.

“Dr. Shafer is actually a good friend, and he actually helped me on a number of the papers,” White testified.

White left behind any hurt feelings as he took the witness stand and matter-of-factly detailed his theory that Jackson must have given himself a fatal dose of propofol. It was the only explanation, White said, for the levels of the drug found in Jackson’s blood and urine during an autopsy.
</ARTICLE>
http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...1/10/31/gIQA2bZOYM_story.html?wprss=rss_music
 
Witness: Jackson's doctor didn't follow protocol
Dr. Paul White acknowledges that pulse monitor Murray used wasn't adequate

Paul Buck / AP
Dr. Conrad Murray could lose his medical license and face four years in jail.By ANTHONY McCARTNEY
updated 7 minutes ago 2011-10-31T18:49:29
LOS ANGELES &#8212; A prosecutor grilling a defense expert got the veteran anesthesiologist to acknowledge Monday that Michael Jackson's doctor deviated from the standard of care.

Dr. Paul White was repeatedly questioned about the ways in which Dr. Conrad Murray had broken guidelines and rules in his treatment of Jackson.
White acknowledged that the type of pulse monitor that Murray was using on Jackson's finger was inadequate to properly monitor the singer when the physician left the room.

Murray, who has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter, has acknowledged he was giving Jackson doses of the anesthetic propofol in the singer's bedroom as a sleep aid. He told police that he left Jackson's room for two minutes on June 25, 2009, and returned to find the pop superstar unresponsive.
White also said he would not leave the room if he were treating a patient who had indicated he liked to inject propofol into himself, as Murray claims that Jackson had told him.

Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor had to interrupt testimony and admonish White after the researcher repeatedly referenced conversations he had with Murray. The judge has excluded testimony about those discussions.
"Dr. White is trying to offer a response he thinks is helpful," Pastor said of White's comments. At one point Monday, White said he had been told that Jackson had his own stash of propofol beyond the hundreds of doses of the drug that Murray had purchased and shipped to his girlfriend's apartment.
Pastor warned White not to try to bring up the conversations or other excluded information again.
"It's deliberate and I don't like it," Pastor said. "It's not going to happen again."

Deputy District Attorney David Walgren pointedly questioned White, a retired professor and clinical researcher, about the circumstances of Murray's care based on his interview with police two days after Jackson's death. White told jurors last week that he believes all the evidence in the case shows that Jackson must have self-administered propofol when Murray left the room.

Walgren and White noted the unique circumstances of the case.
"Have you ever administered propofol in someone's bedroom?" Walgren asked.
"No, I have not," White replied.
"Have you ever heard of someone doing that prior to this case?" the prosecutor asked.
"No, I have not," White responded.
Later, White said Murray's treatment of Jackson was different from how propofol is supposed to be used &#8212; as an anesthetic used in hospital or clinical settings.
"This was an unusual case because the doctor was trying to allow the patient to achieve a sleep state," White said.
White retired last year after conducting research on propofol before it was approved for use in the United States. He told jurors that he has been paid $11,000 for his work on the case so far.
White's testimony has put him at odds with his colleague and longtime friend, Dr. Steven Shafer, who testified for the prosecutor. Shafer said White's self-administration theory is not supported by the evidence in the case, in his view, and he called the theory "crazy" during his testimony earlier this month.

White and Shafer were colleagues at Stanford University and conducted research on propofol before it was approved for use in U.S. operating rooms in 1989. Both help edit a leading anesthesia journal. Until White's retirement last year, both were practicing anesthesiologists.

Shafer said Murray committed 17 egregious violations of the standard of care and should never have been giving the singer propofol as a sleep aid.
"We are in pharmacological never-never land here, something that was done to Michael Jackson and no one else in history to my knowledge," he told jurors.

http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/45102680/ns/today-entertainment/

L.A. NOW
Southern California -- this just in
Defense expert concedes Conrad Murray violated medical care standards [Updated]
October 31, 2011 | 10:30 am

A defense medical expert conceded Monday that Michael Jackson&#8217;s personal physician violated the standard of medical care by providing the pop star with a surgical anesthetic in his home.

At the start of a cross-examination that is expected to last all day, Dr. Paul White, the defense&#8217;s most important witness, acknowledged the treatment the doctor gave Jackson for two months before his death was potentially life-threatening.
&#8220;Without careful bedside monitoring, it could be dangerous,&#8221; said White, a leading anesthesiologist and expert in the drug propofol.
&#8220;Could it result in death?&#8221; a prosecutor pressed.
&#8220;If the infusion somehow came opened up widely &#8230; certainly you could achieve a significant effect that could result in cardiopulmonary arrest,&#8221; White replied.

In testimony Friday, White told jurors that the level of propofol detected in the singer&#8217;s urine after his death suggested he had injected himself with the drug. Murray&#8217;s defense contends Jackson gave himself a lethal dose of propofol in a desperate attempt to sleep before make-or-break rehearsals.
White&#8217;s conclusions were in direct opposition to the findings of a key prosecution expert who testified that the drug evidence showed Murray allowed a massive amount of propofol to enter Jackson&#8217;s body through an intravenous tube.

White admitted when testifying for the defense that he could not explain Murray&#8217;s medical care and Deputy Dist. Atty. David Walgren seized on that point Monday.
&#8220;Have you ever administered propofol in someone&#8217;s bedroom?&#8221; Walgren asked.
&#8220;No, I have not,&#8221; the witness said.
"Had you ever heard of someone doing that prior to this case?&#8221; the prosecutor continued.
&#8220;No, I had not,&#8221; he said.

The prosecutor grilled White about Murray&#8217;s approximately 20-minute delay in summoning an ambulance.
The expert said he would have called 911 immediately, but suggested Murray &#8220;reacted as many physicians would.&#8221;
&#8220;He was probably very anxious and in those situations, it is very stressful for anyone,&#8221; he said.
Walgren ridiculed his response, noting Murray was by his own admission to police holding a cellphone in his hand.
&#8220;Are you saying he wasn&#8217;t capable of pressing 911?&#8221; the prosecutor snapped.
White shrugged off the question, but later said Jackson would have died no matter how quickly help came. At several points, White attempted to relate information he had learned in what he described as &#8220;two extensive conversations&#8221; with Murray.
Those discussions are not admissible in court and the prosecutor objected repeatedly to any references to accounts other than the one Murray gave police.

Judge Michael Pastor chided White to listen carefully to the prosecutor&#8217;s questions.
[Updated 10:39 a.m., Oct. 31: But when the references continued, Pastor sent jurors out of the room to discuss the matter with the lawyers.
Walgren protested that White was intentionally dropping mentions of his conversations with Murray.
Defense attorney J. Michael Flanagan said White could not be expected to specifically recall what information he got from Murray&#8217;s police interview and what information he got from his meetings with Murray.
&#8220;Nice try,&#8221; Pastor said. "This is so obvious .... He&#8217;s trying at every juncture to add in other material. It&#8217;s deliberate, I don&#8217;t like it, it&#8217;s not going to happen again.&#8221;]

Walgren asked White if he believed Murray had broken the physician&#8217;s oath: &#8220;First, do no harm.&#8221;
&#8220;I think he was providing a service to Mr. Jackson which he had requested, in fact insisted upon,&#8221; White replied, referring to the singer&#8217;s requests to numerous medical doctors for propofol to address his chronic insomnia.
The prosecution has previously accused Murray of acting more like an employee than a physician and Walgren emphasized the witness&#8217; use of the term &#8220;service.&#8221;
&#8220;Well, medical care is a better word than service,&#8221; White said.

White said he had been paid $11,000 for his work on the defense so far.
Asked if he expected to receive additional compensation for attending court a dozen days, White said his normal day rate was $3,500, but he did not expect to get it because the defense had &#8220;limited financial resources.&#8221;

Murray, 58, stands accused of involuntary manslaughter. The case is expected to go to the jury later this week. He faces a maximum of four years in prison if convicted.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...des-conrad-murray-violated-care-standard.html
 
Last edited:
Dr. Conrad Murray Will Not Testify In Michael Jackson Death Trial
Posted on Oct 31, 2011 @ 05:00AM
By Jen Heger,
Radar Legal Editor

Dr. Conrad Murray will not be taking the witness stand to testify in his defense in the Michael Jackson death trial, RadarOnline.com is exclusively reporting.

Dr. Murray has been charged with involuntary manslaughter in connection with the King of Pop's death. Testimony will resume Monday with the defense's final witness, Dr. Paul White. Deputy District Attorney David Walgren will be cross examining the propofol expert.

"Dr. Murray has told his lawyers from day one that he wants to testify, and tell his side of events. But lead attorney Ed Chernoff has determined that Dr. Murray will not take the stand because he wouldn't be able to withstand the tough cross examination that the DA would subject him to," a source close to Dr. Murray tells RadarOnline.com.

"Clients always want to testify, but in this case, Walgren would be able to wear him down, and Dr. Murray just wouldn't be able to overcome the basic facts of the case: not calling 911 right away, failure to tell emergency room doctors and first responders that he had given Jackson propofol, and not having the proper monitoring equipment," the source adds.

After the defense formally rests their case, the District Attorney could call several witnesses for rebuttal. "No decision has been made yet if Walgren will be putting on a rebuttal case," a law enforcement insider tells RadarOnline.com.

Dr. White admitted under questioning from one of Murray's lawyers to giving Propofol orally to 'animals.'

As RadarOnline.com previously reported, Dr. Conrad Murray's defense team commissioned a study on Beagle dogs to determine how much of the drug would have to be orally ingested to cause Jackson's death. The defense was forced to abandon that theory after tests proved it would be impossible for someone to die from orally ingesting Propofol.

PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals), filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) alleging "cruel drug toxicity tests on beagles commissioned by the defense team of Dr. Conrad Murray, the physician now on trial for his alleged role in Michael Jackson's death.

&#8220;PETA asserts that if attorneys from Flanagan, Unger, Grover & McCool did commission the tests for the drug Propofol - the toxic effects of which have been extensively studied in dogs and humans - those tests were likely conducted in violation of the federal Animal Welfare Act's prohibition against tests on animals that duplicate previous experiments. PETA has filed a complaint with the State Bar of California as well,"the organization said in their complaint."


If convicted of the involuntary manslaughter charge, Murray could face up to four years in state prison.
http://www.radaronline.com/exclusives/2011/10/conrad-murray-not-testify-michael-jackson-death-trial
 
abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge: there was admonition not 2 refer 2 any statement made by #Murray other than police intvw. I felt strongly enough I dismissed the jury


ACMC_ Michaels Justice
by Mellie4Justice
BREAKING NEWS: Defense Witness Paul White was just served with YET Another Contempt of Court- by judge Pastor ( this is his 2nd charge)

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge: that constitutes direct contempt of court. I'm fining Dr White $1,000. I'll review the matter on Nov. 17. #conradmurraytrial
5 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Here's video of Dr. White's statement today that led Judge Pastor to fine him $!,000 for contempt of court - VIDEO http://bit.ly/uyWmKo



abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
For those of you asking, Dr Steven Shafer is not in the courtroom today. He has not been back in the courtroom since finishing his testimony
7 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Court adjourns for evening recess. Trial will resume tomorrow at 9:30 am PT #conradmurraytrial


mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
According to Judge Pastor's comments at the end of the day, evidence in the case should conclude tomorrow, unless Murray decides to testify.

mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by Mellie4Justice
After jurors left the courtroom, Conrad Murray told a judge he hasn't made final decision about whether to testify: http://apne.ws/u1GkCB
 
Last edited:
L.A. NOW
Southern California -- this just in
Key Conrad Murray witness faces new contempt of court charge
October 31, 2011 | 1:05 pm
The judge overseeing the trial of Michael Jackson&#8217;s personal physician said Monday he was considering finding a key defense witness in contempt of court and fining him $1,000 for violating an order.

Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor said the witness, an anesthesiologist who is the main medical expert for Dr. Conrad Murray&#8217;s defense, violated a court order by mentioning in his testimony conversations he had with Murray.
Pastor had earlier warned Dr. Paul White to keep from mentioning the &#8220;two extensive conversations&#8221; he said he had with Murray, information the judge had previously ruled was inadmissible evidence in the case.
Minutes after the judge&#8217;s admonishment, White again brought up the conversation before jurors, the judge said.
&#8220;That is a direct violation of my order and quite frankly constitutes direct contempt,&#8221; Pastor said.

In his testimony earlier Monday, White hinted at information from those conversations -- that the pop star had his &#8220;own supply&#8221; of propofol, that Murray left a half-filled syringe at Jackson&#8217;s bedside -&#8211; to a prosecutor&#8217;s repeated objections.
Deputy Dist. Atty. David Walgren protested to the judge outside the jury&#8217;s presence that White was intentionally dropping mentions of information from his conversations with Murray.

Defense attorney Michael Flanagan said White could not be expected to specifically recall what information he got from Murray&#8217;s police interview and what information he got from his meetings with the physician.
Pastor said he didn&#8217;t buy that explanation.
&#8220;Nice try,&#8221; Pastor said. "This is so obvious .... He&#8217;s trying at every juncture to add in other material. It&#8217;s deliberate, I don&#8217;t like it, it&#8217;s not going to happen again.&#8221;
Pastor said when White once again referred to the conversation despite his admonishment, it was a direct violation of his order.
The contempt of court charge is the second for White, who was also chided by the judge earlier this month for making comments about a prosecution witness reported on a website.
Pastor said he would hold a hearing on both contempt charges Nov. 16.

In his testimony Monday, White, an expert on the anesthetic propofol, elaborated on the theory he first gave last week.
Jackson, he testified, probably injected himself with a syringe Murray had filled with 25 milligrams of propofol and laid near his bedside.
He said that when Murray was distracted by a series of phone calls, Jackson woke up and got the syringe.
&#8220;It was some time during that 40-minute period where I believe Mr. Jackson had the opportunity and likely self-administrated the final fatal dose of propofol,&#8221; he said.

Walgren noted that Jackson was attached to an IV stand and a urinary catheter and suggested it was more plausible for Murray to have injected the propofol and then lied about the amount he gave.
&#8220;It&#8217;s possible if he wanted to potentially harm Michael Jackson,&#8221; White replied.
&#8220;If Michael Jackson did it, was he doing it to harm himself?&#8221; Walgren asked.
&#8220;I don&#8217;t think he realized the potential danger,&#8221; the witness answered.
The exchanges between the witness and prosecutor were testy at times, with Walgren remarking: &#8220;You keep throwing out these kind of rehearsed lines.&#8221;
A defense attorney objected, and the comment was stricken.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...t-pondered-for-key-conrad-murray-witness.html
 
Conrad Murray Trial: Prosecutor Tears Into Defense Expert (Live Feed) - Update 1
By Kimberly Potts
The Wrap &#8211; 2 hours 15 minutes ago Update, 12:05 p.m. PT

Prosecution attorney David Walgren aggressively questioned anesthesiology expert Dr. Paul White, the final witness for the defense in the involuntary manslaughter trial of Conrad Murray on Monday, challenging White's theory on how Michael Jackson received his fatal dose of the anesthetic propofol, as well as using White's own words to paint Murray's care of Jackson grossly inadequate.

Under Walgren's questioning, White -- who maintains that Jackson most likely self-injected the dose of propofol that killed him -- admitted that Murray probably left Jackson unattended for a 35 to 40 minute period, during which the singer presumably gave himself the fatal dose of propofol. During an interview with police conducted two days after Jackson's death, Murray maintained that he had only left Jackson alone for two minutes, to take a bathroom break.
White also admitted that Jackson likely performed the injection with a syringe that Murray had prepared, then left within Jackson's reach -- which didn't exactly speak well of Murray's care and diligence.

Perhaps most damningly, Walgren presented passages on the use of anesthesia in an out-patient setting authored by White himself, which detailed the necessary components when administering anesthesia in a non-hospital setting. Many of the essential components -- such as the "continuous presence of a member of the anesthesia care team" and a written plan for emergency transport -- weren't present during Murray's treatment of Jackson.

One of White's articles stated that "vigilant monitoring is required" when administering anesthesia, as the patient could quickly slip from mild to deep sedation, "and thus may be at risk for airway obstruction, oxygen desaturation and even aspiration."
Under repeated grilling from Walgren, White reluctantly opined that the standard of care laid out in his guidelines should at least be matched when administering propofol in a patient's bedroom.
White went so far as to admit, "I would not administer propofol in a bedroom."
Asked whether he would have done as Murray had and allow himself to be hired by Jackson to give him nightly doses of propofol for his insomnia, White replied, "Absolutely not. That would be a job that I would never consider accepting."

In what could be the most dramatic day of the Conrad Murray involuntary manslaughter trial, prosecutor David Walgren will cross-examine Dr. Paul White, the defense team anesthesiologist expert -- and final witness -- who testified that he believes Michael Jackson gave himself his fatal dose of drugs.

Supporting the defense, White testified on Friday that the amount of drugs found in Jackson's system led him to believe that Jackson died after injecting himself with propofol and swallowing a large dose of lorazepam without Murray's knowledge.
White's conclusion is in direct opposition to that of prosecution propofol expert Dr. Steve Shafer -- a White colleague and former student -- who testified earlier in the trial that he believes the "only scenario" that explains Jackson's death is that Murray put the singer on a constant IV drip of propofol in the hours before his death.
White called the prosecution's theory "befuddling."

CNN.com reports that closing arguments could happen as soon as Tuesday, and that the trial that began on Sept. 27 should be in the hands of the jury by the middle of this week.

Murray faces up to four years in prison and loss of his medical license if convicted, though a new California law could mean his sentence would be reduced to two years and be served in a county jail.

http://movies.yahoo.com/news/conrad-murray-trial-prosecutor-tears-defense-expert-live-193802061.html
 
Oct 31, 7:36 PM EDT
Jackson doc: no decision on whether he'll testify
By LINDA DEUTSCH
AP Special Correspondent
LOS ANGELES (AP) -- The doctor charged in Michael Jackson's death says he hasn't made a final decision about whether or not he will testify in his own defense.

Dr. Conrad Murray told Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor that he has thought about whether to testify and has consulted with his attorney. But Murray says he hasn't made a final decision and will advise the judge in the morning of his decision.
Pastor asked Murray if he had made a decision after jurors had left the courtroom on Monday.
The judge told Murray he has a constitutional right to testify and the right to testify. He has previously given Murray the same advisement of his rights.
Pastor says attorneys told him that the evidence phase of the case may conclude on Tuesday.

THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE.
Dr. Conrad Murray heard his own expert witness testify Monday that he wouldn't have accepted payment to do what Murray did for Michael Jackson - administering a hospital anesthetic in the star's bedroom.
"I wouldn't even consider it," Dr. Paul White said. "It's something no amount of money could convince me to take on."
The use of the drug propofol to treat Jackson's insomnia was "a complete off-label use of the drug," he said. White also acknowledged that the drug should never be given outside a medical facility because of the need for proper lifesaving equipment.

White, a highly regarded and now-retired anesthesiologist, is sometimes referred to as "the father of propofol" for his early research on the drug. But on Monday he was a less than respected figure, drawing criticism from the prosecutor and censure from the judge who threatened to fine him $1,000 for contempt of court.

White came under a bruising cross-examination by prosecutor David Walgren who attacked the expert's recent claim that Jackson caused his own death. Walgren questioned White's scientific calculations and noted he once led the defense to think Jackson drank an extra dose of propofol.
White acknowledged he had done no research on that theory when he posed it. A study later showed the theory to be unsupportable, he said.

While stopping short of blaming Murray for the singer's death, White blurted out during cross-examination that he believed Murray had loaded a syringe with the drug propofol and left it where Jackson could have gained access to it.
That scenario had not been offered before and it could explain how a groggy Jackson could have awakened from sedation, grabbed the syringe and injected the drug into his IV line.

Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor told White outside the jury's presence to stop trying to sneak in references to private conversations he had with Murray. The witness had suggested his opinions were partially based on what Murray told him, but those talks are not in evidence.
At one point Monday, White said he had been told by Murray that Jackson had his own stash of propofol beyond the hundreds of bottles of the drug that Murray had purchased and shipped to his girlfriend's apartment. Pastor warned White not to try to bring up the conversations or other excluded information again.
"It's deliberate and I don't like it," Pastor said. "It's not going to happen again."
But by the end of the morning the judge said White had violated his order. Outside the jury's presence, he chastised the witness for telling the jurors at one point: "I'd like to talk to you about this but the judge told me I couldn't."
He said he considered that remark direct contempt of court but would allow White to explain at a contempt hearing on Nov. 16 before he imposes the $1,000 fine.

White was repeatedly questioned about the ways in which Murray had broken guidelines and rules governing the use of propofol. Walgren confronted the witness with excerpts from his own writings in textbooks which set down rules that Murray broke by administering the drug in Jackson's bedroom.

He also challenged a series of charts presented to the jury by White. The expert said he had not prepared them and had another expert do the work. He said he was not an expert in preparing such mathematical models.

Walgren completed his cross-examination and defense attorney J. Michael Flanagan took over trying to justify Murray's actions after he found Jackson not breathing. White suggested that by that time, Jackson was probably dead and it would not have mattered if paramedics were called quickly. Murray has said he delayed calling 9-1-1 while trying to give Jackson CPR.
The witness also said it would not have helped if Murray had disclosed to paramedics or hospital workers that he had given Jackson propofol.

Murray, who has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter, has acknowledged he was giving Jackson doses of the anesthetic propofol in the singer's bedroom as a sleep aid. He told police that he left Jackson's room for two minutes on June 25, 2009, and returned to find the pop superstar unresponsive.
White said in forming his opinions, he assumed Murray was out of the room much longer, making phone calls.
The retired anesthesiologist also said he would not leave the room if he were treating a patient who had indicated he liked to inject propofol into himself, as Murray claims that Jackson had told him.

"Have you ever administered propofol in someone's bedroom?" Walgren asked.
"No, I have not," White replied.
"Have you ever heard of someone doing that prior to this case?" the prosecutor asked.
"No, I have not," White responded.
White said he has been paid $11,000 for his work for the defense so far.
White's testimony has put him at odds with his colleague and longtime friend, Dr. Steven Shafer, who testified for the prosecutor. Shafer said White's self-administration theory is not supported by the evidence in the case, in his view, and he called the theory "crazy" during his testimony earlier this month.

White and Shafer were colleagues at Stanford University and conducted research on propofol before it was approved for use in U.S. operating rooms in 1989. Both help edit a leading anesthesia journal. Until White's retirement last year, both were practicing anesthesiologists.

Shafer may be called as a rebuttal witness later in the trial, which is now in its sixth week.

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/storie...CTOR?SITE=VACUL&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT

Dr. Murray considers testifying about Michael Jackson's death
By Alan Duke, CNN
November 1, 2011 -- Updated 0719 GMT (1519 HKT)

Los Angeles (CNN) -- Dr. Conrad Murray will tell the judge in his involuntary manslaughter trial Tuesday morning if he will take the stand to defend himself against the charge that he is criminally responsible for Michael Jackson's death.
If Murray chooses to remain silent, testimony in the trial is likely to end Tuesday and closing arguments will be delivered Thursday, the judge said.

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor appeared surprised Monday afternoon when Murray told him he still has not decided if he will testify and he needed more time to confer with his lawyers.
Pastor gave him until the start of court Tuesday to decide since it is likely to be the last day for testimony in the trial.

White doubts Murray felt Jackson's pulse The prosecution contends that Murray's use of the surgical anesthetic propofol to treat Jackson's insomnia in his home deviated from the standards of care expected of a doctor so egregiously that it was criminal.

If Murray wants jurors to hear his version of what happened the day the world's biggest pop star died under his care, it would be at the risk of intensive cross-examination by Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney David Walgren.

Walgren proved his cross-examination skills again Monday in a fiery battle with Dr. Paul White over the defense anesthesiology expert's theory that Michael Jackson died from drugs he gave himself.
White's bruises in the battle included a contempt of court citation and a $1,000 fine after he ignored repeated warnings from the judge not to refer to his personal conversations with Murray.

Walgren insisted that White answer his questions based only on what he knew from Murray's interview with police, not what Murray told him privately. It otherwise would have been a way for the defense to introduce statements from the defendant without him having to testify.
"Nice try," Pastor told the defense as he ruled they couldn't do that.

Walgren spent much of Monday trying to discredit what White said during his testimony Friday, and getting the defense expert to support the prosecution's argument that Murray's treatment of Jackson was reckless.
White conceded that Murray deviated from the standards of care, but he would not agree that they were so "egregious and extreme" that they make Murray criminally responsible for Jackson's death. Murray's deviations were "perhaps between minor and serious, but it's not extreme," he said.

Walgren also was successful in getting White to agree that he would not have done what Murray did -- take the job of sedating Jackson nearly every night at home with propofol.
"No amount of money" could get him to take the job, White said. "Absolutely not," he testified. "That would be a job I would never consider accepting."
The prosecution contends greed led Murray to leave his medical practice and put his ethics aside to serve as Jackson's private doctor for $150,000 a month.

But the biggest battle between Walgren and White was fought over the competing theories of how Jackson died and the scientific evidence that supports them.

The Los Angeles County coroner ruled that Jackson's June 25, 2009, death was caused by "acute propofol intoxication" in combination with two sedatives.

White concluded that the level of drugs found in Jackson's stomach, blood and urine, convinced him that Jackson died after he rapidly injected himself with propofol on top of a large dose of lorazepam he swallowed hours earlier.

The prosecution's propofol expert, Dr. Steven Shafer, concluded the "only scenario" that fits the scientific evidence is that Jackson was on a constant IV drip of propofol for three hours before his death.
Shafer also testified that Murray must have also injected Jackson with a series of large doses of lorazepam, a sedative, hours before his death.

White theorized that Jackson could have "pushed" the drug into an catheter in his leg using a syringe over a 15- to 30-second period, much faster than a doctor would have done. "I believe it could potentially have lethal consequences," White testified.

Under cross-examination Monday, White said he believed Jackson used the same syringe Murray had loaded with propofol an hour earlier to give Jackson a 25-milligram injection. Murray filled it with 50-milligrams initially, leaving it half-filled in Jackson's bedroom, under White's theory.
White ruled out the possibility that Murray would have injected the fatal dose unless "he wanted to potentially harm Mr. Jackson."

Walgren asked White if he thought Jackson intended to harm himself.
"I don't think he realized the potential danger," White replied.

The defense contends Jackson was desperate for sleep, fearing his comeback concerts would be canceled if he missed another rehearsal from lack of rest.

Walgren pressed White for an opinion about Murray's decision to leave Jackson alone with a syringe of propofol, considering he should have known Jackson had "pushed" a syringe of propofol before.
"No, I would not leave the room," he said.

Prosecutors contend Murray is responsible for Jackson's death, even if he did not give him the final and fatal dose, because he was reckless in using the surgical anesthetic to help Jackson sleep without proper precautions.

White is expected to be back on the witness stand for a short time Tuesday morning, before the defense calls a scientist with a background in bio-engineering to explain charts outlining propofol levels found in Jackson's urine.

The prosecution indicated it would recall Shafer to answer a few more questions in rebuttal to White before both sides rest in the trial that started in late September.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/11/01/justice/california-conrad-murray-trial/
 
Last edited:
abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
#MichaelJackson's family present so far: Katherine, Joe and Randy. #conradmurraytrial

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
#BREAKINGNEWS: Dr. #ConradMurray will NOT testify on his behalf. #MichaelJackson


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
#BREAKINGNEWS: Defense will rest. Prosecution is now deciding whether they will call rebuttal witness. #conradmurraytrial


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
#BREAKINGNEWS: Dr #Murray to judge: "My decision is that I will not testify in this matter." Judge Pastor accepted Murray's waiver

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
#BREAKINGNEWS: Dr. #Murray's defense team is ready to rest, told judge they will not call another witness after all.


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Prosecution asked for 30 minutes to decide whether they will recall Dr. Steven Shafer or not.


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge told #Murray decision to testify is personal rt to him and him alone. "It does not belong to your lawyer, prosecuting lawyer, family"

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge to Murray: so you're freely and voluntarily giving up your right to testify and making decision based on your own free will? Yes.


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
by Mellie4Justice
Judge to #Murray: the right NOT to testify also belongs to you and you alone. The two constitutional rights are at polar opposites.


mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
No, she won't be called. RT @posmike: @mccartneyAP Is Dr. Ornelis (sp?) not going to testify?

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
La Toya Jackson just arrived in the courtroom. Family present now: Katherine, Joe, Randy and La Toya. #conradmurraytrial

mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
Both sides are done with Dr. Shafer - may be at the end of testimony here. #murraytrial


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Dr. Shafer is excused. Judge asked to speak with the attorneys at sidebar. #conradmurraytrial


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Both prosecution and defense have rested their case. Judge tells jurors they have seen all of the evidence in this case. #conradmurraytrial


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Stipulated that exhibit People's 52 accurately reflect the names and phone numbers of people mentioned. #conradmurraytrial


mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
Jury is being excused until 9 am on Thursday. #murraytrial


InSession In Session
Closing arguments will begin Thursday morning. #MurrayTrial

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge ordered jurors to return on Thursday at 9 am for further proceedings. By then, jury instructions/verdict form need to be concluded.


abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
Judge has ordered attorneys back into the courtroom this afternoon at 2 to discuss jury instructions so they can all prepare their closing

abc7MurrayTrial ABC7 Murray Trial
by MJJNews
Attorneys will use the time to tie-up the exhibits with their closing arguments, so they can refer back & forth while presenting final words
 
Last edited:
L.A. NOW
Southern California -- this just in
Dr. Conrad Murray declines to testify in Michael Jackson death trial
November 1, 2011 | 10:45 am

Michael Jackson&#8217;s doctor will not testify at his trial for involuntary manslaughter, he said in court Tuesday.
&#8220;My decision is that I will not testify in this matter,&#8221; Dr. Conrad Murray said.

Had he chosen to take the stand in the downtown Los Angeles courthouse, Murray likely would have faced blistering cross-examination by prosecutors.
Witnesses have testified that he lied numerous times and made egregious medical missteps in the care of the music superstar.

After informing Murray of his dual constitutional rights to testify and to remain silent, Judge Michael Pastor asked the doctor Tuesday, &#8220;What is your decision?&#8221;
Murray paused, looked to his lead defense attorney Ed Chernoff and then to his left at two other lawyers and said, &#8220;My decision is to not testify -- .&#8221;
His response was interrupted by a prosecutor who objected to a &#8220;narrative answer.&#8221; The judge asked Murray again and he replied, &#8220;My decision is that I will not testify in this matter.&#8221;
The judge asked Murray if his decision was his alone.
&#8220;You are making this decision based on your own free will?&#8221; Pastor asked.
&#8220;Yes,&#8221; Murray said.
Chernoff added that he had conferred with his client about the decision &#8220;many times&#8221; and that the doctor understood his rights &#8220;very well.&#8221;

Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Jackson's death.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2011/11/conrad-murray-declines-testify-michael-jackson.html


Murray remains silent as testimony ends in Jackson death trial
By Alan Duke, CNN
November 1, 2011 -- Updated 1924 GMT (0324 HKT)

Los Angeles (CNN) -- Dr. Conrad Murray announced in court Tuesday that he will not testify in his involuntary manslaughter trial.
Murray paused and looked at each of his lawyers for several seconds before telling the judge, "My decision is that I will not testify in this matter."
His decision to remain silent brought to an end the defense case in the trial of Michael Jackson's doctor, setting the stage for closing arguments on Thursday. Lawyers have been given Wednesday off from court to prepare their arguments.

A Michael Jackson fan was removed from the courthouse after yelling "Murderer, Murderer" at Murray as he walked down the hallway during a recess late Tuesday morning.

Jackson fans lined both sides of the hallway and held hands as members of Jackson's family walked past at the end of the morning session.
Parents Joe and Katherine Jackson attended court Tuesday, along with their youngest son, Randy Jackson.

Prosecutors briefly recalled their anesthesiology expert, Dr. Steven Shafer, for a rebuttal to defense propofol expert Dr. Paul White before resting their case Tuesday morning.

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor will meet with lawyers for both sides Tuesday afternoon to discuss what exhibits will be admitted into evidence and what instructions he will give to jurors before they begin deliberations Thursday afternoon.

The prosecution contends that Murray's use of the surgical anesthetic propofol to treat Jackson's insomnia in his home deviated from the standards of care expected of a doctor so egregiously that it made him criminally responsible for Jackson's death.

If Murray had decided to tell jurors his version of what happened the day the world's biggest pop star died under his care, it would have been at the risk of intensive cross-examination by Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney David Walgren.

Walgren proved his cross-examination skills again Monday in a fiery battle with Dr. Paul White over the defense anesthesiology expert's theory that Jackson died from drugs he gave himself.
White completed his testimony Tuesday morning.
White's bruises in his battle with Walgren on Monday included a contempt-of-court citation and a $1,000 fine after he ignored repeated warnings from Pastor not to refer to his personal conversations with Murray.
Walgren insisted that White answer his questions based only on what he knew from Murray's interview with police, not what Murray told him privately. It otherwise would have been a way for the defense to introduce statements from the defendant without him having to testify.
"Nice try," Pastor told the defense as he ruled they couldn't do that.

Walgren spent much of Monday trying to discredit what White said during his testimony Friday, and getting the defense expert to support the prosecution's argument that Murray's treatment of Jackson was reckless.
White conceded that Murray deviated from the standards of care, but he would not agree that they were so "egregious and extreme" that they make Murray criminally responsible for Jackson's death. Murray's deviations were "perhaps between minor and serious, but it's not extreme," he said.
Walgren also was successful in getting White to agree that he would not have done what Murray did -- take the job of sedating Jackson nearly every night at home with propofol.
"No amount of money" could get him to take the job, White said. "Absolutely not," he testified. "That would be a job I would never consider accepting."

The prosecution contends greed led Murray to leave his medical practice and put his ethics aside to serve as Jackson's private doctor for $150,000 a month.
But the biggest battle between Walgren and White was fought over the competing theories of how Jackson died and the scientific evidence that supports them.
The Los Angeles County coroner ruled that Jackson's June 25, 2009, death was caused by "acute propofol intoxication" in combination with two sedatives.

White concluded that the level of drugs found in Jackson's stomach, blood and urine, convinced him that Jackson died after he rapidly injected himself with propofol on top of a large dose of lorazepam he swallowed hours earlier.

Shafer, the prosecution's propofol expert, concluded the "only scenario" that fits the scientific evidence is that Jackson was on a constant intravenous drip of propofol for three hours before his death.
Shafer also testified that Murray must have also injected Jackson with a series of large doses of lorazepam, a sedative, hours before his death.

White theorized that Jackson could have "pushed" the drug into an catheter in his leg using a syringe over a 15- to 30-second period, much faster than a doctor would have done. "I believe it could potentially have lethal consequences," White testified.
Under cross-examination Monday, White said he believed Jackson used the same syringe Murray had loaded with propofol an hour earlier to give Jackson a 25-milligram injection. Murray filled it with 50 milligrams initially, leaving it half-filled in Jackson's bedroom, under White's theory.
White ruled out the possibility that Murray would have injected the fatal dose unless "he wanted to potentially harm Mr. Jackson."
Walgren asked White whether he thought Jackson intended to harm himself.
"I don't think he realized the potential danger," White replied.
The defense contends Jackson was desperate for sleep, fearing his comeback concerts would be canceled if he missed another rehearsal from lack of rest.
Walgren pressed White for an opinion about Murray's decision to leave Jackson alone with a syringe of propofol, considering he should have known Jackson had "pushed" a syringe of propofol before.
"No, I would not leave the room," he said.

Prosecutors contend Murray is responsible for Jackson's death, even if he did not give him the final and fatal dose, because he was reckless in using the surgical anesthetic to help Jackson sleep without proper precautions.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/11/01/justice/california-conrad-murray-trial/
 
Last edited:
Much Thanks to Elusive ^

Testimony ends in Michael Jackson doctor trial
LINDA DEUTSCH
Published: Today

LOS ANGELES (AP) - Michael Jackson's doctor finally made a decision he had long delayed, telling a judge Tuesday he would not testify in his involuntary manslaughter trial.

Minutes later, the defense rested its case and the prosecution, after presenting brief rebuttal testimony, closed its presentation of evidence in the six-week trial. That set the stage for closing arguments to begin Thursday.

Dr. Conrad Murray's announcement came while jurors were out of the room and he was not asked to repeat it for them.

Spectators, including Jackson's mother, father, brother Randy and sister LaToya, seemed to hold their breath before Murray answered one of the biggest remaining questions of his trial, saying he would stay away from the witness stand.

The doctor held his hands together over his mouth in a prayerful pose before Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor asked the cardiologist whether he intended to take the stand.
The judge lectured Murray as he had before on how the decision to testify was his alone and that he also had the right to remain silent.
"Have you made up your mind?" Pastor asked.
Murray paused, looked at all his lawyers, seemed to sigh and said, "My decision is I will not testify in this matter."
The judge asked lead attorney Ed Chernoff if he had conferred with Murray about his rights and Chernoff said yes.

"The court finds the defendant has knowingly, freely and explicitly waived his right to testify," the judge said. "I certainly will respect that decision."
Murray had left open the possibility of testifying on Monday, when he told the judge that he had not made a final decision.
The judge had warned him that testifying brought with it the prospect of tough cross-examination by the prosecution. That may have swayed him along with the fact that the jury already had a chance to hear him tell his story on a recording of a police interview.

When jurors returned to the courtroom, Chernoff announced that the defense had no further witnesses after calling 16 people to testify. A total of 49 witnesses testified for both sides over 22 days of trial.

Prosecutors contend Murray gave Jackson a fatal dose of the anesthetic propofol in the bedroom of the singer's mansion. Defense attorneys claim Jackson self-administered the dose when Murray left the room.

The last witness was propofol expert Dr. Steven Shafer, who was re-called by prosecutors as a rebuttal witness to address a few points raised by his former colleague Dr. Paul White.

In the final moments of testimony by White, he was asked by defense attorney J. Michael Flanagan to differentiate between the "standard of care" and the "standard of practice" by physicians. Prosecution expert witnesses have said Murray's treatment of Jackson was an extreme deviation from the accepted standard of care.
"The standard of care is the ideal," White said. "It is what we would look for for every patient."
But he suggested there are unique situations in which the standard must be adjusted to circumstances and may not reach the highest level.
White has testified for the defense that Jackson caused his own death. But White also said he would not have followed the same procedures that Murray did.

Addressing the standard of care issue, Shafer said that in special cases such as that of Jackson, where a patient is treated in a remote location, the precautions should be above the standard of care, not below.
Noting that Jackson was given the drug propofol in his bedroom, he said, "If there was such a thing as bedroom-based anesthesia, the standard guidelines would be a minimum. There's no tolerance for error because you have no backup."

Murray has pleaded not guilty to involuntary manslaughter in Jackson's death on June 25, 2009. He could face up to four years behind bars and the loss of his medical license if convicted.

http://m.apnews.mobi/ap/db_6776/contentdetail.htm?contentguid=7VxiwTei


L.A. NOW
Southern California -- this just in
Conrad Murray's fate soon to be in jury's hands as testimony ends
November 1, 2011 | 12:51 pm

Prosecutors and defense attorneys rested their case Tuesday morning in the involuntary manslaughter trial of Michael Jackson&#8217;s personal physician.

The final witness was government expert Dr. Steven Shafer, who was briefly recalled to the stand to reiterate his earlier testimony that Dr. Conrad Murray probably left an intravenous drip of the anesthetic propofol running into Jackson&#8217;s veins after the singer&#8217;s heart stopped.
Shafer refuted a defense expert&#8217;s testimony that levels of the drug found in Jackson&#8217;s urine proved he was wrong. In that analysis, Dr. Paul White relied on an outdated 1988 study, Shafer said. In fact, more recent research on the drug supports his hypothesis on what happened in the hours leading up to the pop star&#8217;s death, Shafer testified.
The anesthesiologist, an expert on propofol, said the latest research also illustrated that Jackson could not have given himself an injection of the drug, the scenario White said was more likely.
&#8220;Does it absolutely rule out the hypothesis put forth by Dr. White?&#8221; Deputy Dist. Atty. David Walgren asked.
&#8220;Absolutely,&#8221; Shafer responded.

White, the defense&#8217;s final witness, completed his four-day testimony earlier Tuesday, during which he attacked the conclusions Shafer drew in the case.
Once White was off the stand, Murray told the judge that he will not be taking the stand in his own defense. After Shafer finished his testimony, both sides said they had no more witnesses.

&#8220;Ladies and gentlemen, you&#8217;ve seen and heard all of the evidence in this case,&#8221; Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor told jurors at the downtown L.A. courthouse.

Defense attorneys called 16 witnesses to the stand in their weeklong case, including patients who painted Murray as a competent, caring doctor, and an addiction expert who testified that Jackson was probably an addict. A total of 49 witnesses have testified in the trial.

Closing arguments are set to begin Thursday morning. Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Jackson's death.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2011/11/conrad-murray-testimony-ends.html
 
Last edited:
mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by MJJNews
@ .@TsuDhoNimh @JohnMone Finally, today's session will be first time they've discussed instructions. Judge has been asking 4 input 4 days


mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by MJJNews
@ .@TsuDhoNimh @JohnMone Judge wants attys to focus on how to craft involuntary manslaughter instruction re "causation" - that's his word.

mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by MJJNews
@ .@TsuDhoNimh @JohnMone He also wants input on how to craft instruction on character evidence. He wants defense to spell out which traits

mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by MJJNews
@ .@TsuDhoNimh @JohnMone ... Of Murray's the jury should consider. In CA, character evidence can be used to establish reasonable doubt.


mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by MJJNews
On a break - Judge Pastor is intent on getting jury instructions finalized today. Also getting all the exhibits finalized.


mccartneyAP Anthony McCartney
by MJJNews
There has been no discussion of how long Murray case closing arguments will be. #murraytrial
 
Lawyers in Conrad Murray trial prepare closing arguments
By Alan Duke, CNN
November 2, 2011 -- Updated 0527 GMT (1327 HKT)

Los Angeles (CNN) -- Lawyers in the Conrad Murray manslaughter trial will take Wednesday off from court to prepare their closing arguments, a day after the doctor declined to testify in his defense in the death of singer Michael Jackson.

Murray announced in court Tuesday that he will not take the stand, pausing to look at each of his lawyers for several seconds before telling the judge, "My decision is that I will not testify in this matter."
His decision to remain silent ended the defense case in the trial of Michael Jackson's doctor, setting the stage for closing arguments on Thursday.

The end of testimony was emotional for dozens of the singer's fans who converged at the Los Angeles County courthouse during the six-week trial.
A fan was removed from the courthouse after yelling "Murderer, Murderer" at Murray as he walked down the hallway during a recess Tuesday.

Fans also surrounded and yelled at defense anesthesiology expert Dr. Paul White as he waited for a cab on a courthouse sidewalk. Others lined both sides of the hallway and held hands as members of Jackson's family walked past.

Parents Joe and Katherine Jackson attended court Tuesday, along with their daughter, LaToya Jackson and youngest son, Randy Jackson.

As Katherine and LaToya left the courthouse, they took with them several signs used by fans in loud protests each day.

Prosecutors briefly recalled their anesthesiology expert, Dr. Steven Shafer, for a rebuttal to defense propofol expert Dr. Paul White before resting their case Tuesday morning.

Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor met with lawyers for both sides Tuesday afternoon to discuss what exhibits will be admitted into evidence and what instructions he will give jurors before they begin deliberations Thursday.

The prosecution contends that Murray's use of the surgical anesthetic propofol to treat Jackson's insomnia in his home deviated from the standards of care expected of a doctor so egregiously that it made him criminally responsible for Jackson's death.

Witness' many theories on Jackson death If Murray had decided to tell jurors his version of what happened the day the pop star died under his care, it would have been at the risk of intensive cross-examination by Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney David Walgren.

Walgren proved his cross-examination skills again Monday in a fiery battle with White over the defense anesthesiology expert's theory that Jackson died from drugs he gave himself.

White completed his testimony Tuesday morning.
White's bruises in his battle with Walgren on Monday included a contempt-of-court citation and a $1,000 fine after he ignored repeated warnings from Pastor not to refer to his personal conversations with Murray.
Walgren insisted that White answer his questions based only on what he knew from Murray's interview with police, not what Murray told him privately. It otherwise would have been a way for the defense to introduce statements from the defendant without him having to testify.
"Nice try," Pastor told the defense as he ruled they couldn't do that.

Walgren spent much of Monday trying to discredit what White said during his testimony Friday, and getting the defense expert to support the prosecution's argument that Murray's treatment of Jackson was reckless.
White conceded that Murray deviated from the standards of care, but he would not agree that they were so "egregious and extreme" that they make Murray criminally responsible for Jackson's death. Murray's deviations were "perhaps between minor and serious, but it's not extreme," he said.

Walgren also was successful in getting White to agree that he would not have done what Murray did -- take the job of sedating Jackson nearly every night at home with propofol.
"No amount of money" could get him to take the job, White said. "Absolutely not," he testified. "That would be a job I would never consider accepting."

The prosecution contends greed led Murray to leave his medical practice and put his ethics aside to serve as Jackson's private doctor for $150,000 a month.

But the biggest battle between Walgren and White was fought over the competing theories of how Jackson died and the scientific evidence that supports them.

The Los Angeles County coroner ruled that Jackson's June 25, 2009, death was caused by "acute propofol intoxication" in combination with two sedatives.

White concluded that the level of drugs found in Jackson's stomach, blood and urine, convinced him that Jackson died after he rapidly injected himself with propofol on top of a large dose of lorazepam he swallowed hours earlier.

Shafer, the prosecution's propofol expert, concluded the "only scenario" that fits the scientific evidence is that Jackson was on a constant intravenous drip of propofol for three hours before his death.
Shafer also testified that Murray must have also injected Jackson with a series of large doses of lorazepam, a sedative, hours before his death.

White theorized that Jackson could have "pushed" the drug into an catheter in his leg using a syringe over a 15- to 30-second period, much faster than a doctor would have done.
"I believe it could potentially have lethal consequences," White testified.
Under cross-examination Monday, White said he believed Jackson used the same syringe Murray had loaded with propofol an hour earlier to give Jackson a 25-milligram injection. Murray filled it with 50 milligrams initially, leaving it half-filled in Jackson's bedroom, under White's theory.
White ruled out the possibility that Murray would have injected the fatal dose unless "he wanted to potentially harm Mr. Jackson."
Walgren asked White whether he thought Jackson intended to harm himself.
"I don't think he realized the potential danger," White replied.
The defense contends Jackson was desperate for sleep, fearing his comeback concerts would be canceled if he missed another rehearsal from lack of rest.
Walgren pressed White for an opinion about Murray's decision to leave Jackson alone with a syringe of propofol, considering he should have known Jackson had "pushed" a syringe of propofol before.
"No, I would not leave the room," he said.

Prosecutors contend Murray is responsible for Jackson's death, even if he did not give him the final and fatal dose, because he was reckless in using the surgical anesthetic to help Jackson sleep without proper precautions.

http://edition.cnn.com/2011/11/02/justice/california-conrad-murray-trial/index.html?eref=rss_us
 
Jurors won&#8217;t hear Jackson doctor testify, but will enter deliberations with plenty to consider

By Associated Press, Updated: Wednesday, November 2, 7:38 AM
LOS ANGELES &#8212; Jurors hearing the involuntary manslaughter case against Michael Jackson&#8217;s doctor will not hear directly from the man whose fate they will soon be asked to decide.

Instead the panel will have to choose whether to convict or acquit Dr. Conrad Murray of based on the testimony of 49 witnesses and hundreds of pieces of evidence, including one lengthy police interview with the cardiologist.


Dr. Murray decided not to testify for his defense. Murray has pleaded not guilty and faces four years in prison and the loss of his medical licenses if convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Jackson&#8217;s death.
The seven-man, five-woman panel didn&#8217;t get to hear Murray announce his decision Tuesday, but were rather told by a judge after testimony from a pair of medical experts that there would be no more evidence presented to them.
They were given Wednesday off, which prosecutors and defense attorneys will use to craft their closing arguments &#8212; the final words of the case before deliberations begin.

Murray&#8217;s decision Tuesday came after 22 days of testimony and serious thought by the doctor, who told Superior Court Judge Michael Pastor the day before that he hadn&#8217;t ruled out taking the stand. In the moments before the announcement, with jurors still in the room and the judge huddling with attorneys at a sidebar conference, the doctor held his hands in front of his face, as if in prayer.
Jurors were excused from the courtroom while Pastor advised Murray of his rights to testify or remain silent.
Spectators, including Jackson&#8217;s mother, father, brother Randy and sister LaToya, watched from the audience as the judge asked Murray, &#8220;Have you made up your mind?&#8221;

Murray paused, looked at all his lawyers, seemed to sigh and said, &#8220;My decision is I will not testify in this matter.&#8221;
Pastor said Murray had properly weighed his options and added, &#8220;I certainly will respect that decision.&#8221;

Murray, 58, has pleaded not guilty in connection with Jackson&#8217;s June 2009 death. He faces up to four years behind bars and the loss of his medical license if convicted.

Prosecutors contend Murray gave Jackson a fatal dose of the anesthetic propofol in the bedroom of the singer&#8217;s mansion. Defense attorneys claim Jackson gave himself the dose when Murray left the room.

Jurors were presented with dueling scientific evidence to support each side&#8217;s theory, although even a defense expert noted he would not have given the pop singer propofol in his bedroom for any sum of money.

Murray told police two days after Jackson&#8217;s death that he had been giving the singer the powerful anesthetic nightly for nearly two months. After the singer&#8217;s death, police found bags with basic medical equipment and vials of propofol, but not the advanced equipment prosecutors and experts say the doctor should have had to be administering propofol.

Pastor and attorneys spent Tuesday afternoon finalizing jury instructions, which will give the panel its guidelines for how to view the case. Prosecutors are saying that while Murray was engaged in lawful practices during his treatment of Jackson, he was criminally negligent in many of his actions. The panel will be told that they can consider whether Murray should have known that Jackson&#8217;s death was a foreseeable consequence of his actions.

Defense attorneys will be able to highlight the testimony of five character witnesses &#8212; which jurors will be told can be sufficient to create reasonable doubt &#8212; to illustrate seven traits they claim the doctor has displayed throughout his career: being attentive, informative, skillful, cautious, compassionate, loyal and knowledgeable.

They can also consider whether the character witnesses demonstrated that Murray is selfless and not financially motivated. Prosecutors have cast him as greedy and eager to please Jackson, who had agreed to pay the physician $150,000 per month. The singer died before the contract was finalized.

Although they won&#8217;t have any direct testimony from the Houston-based cardiologist to consider, the jury will be able to review the doctor&#8217;s lengthy police statement, in which he both detailed his treatments to Jackson and left out any references to his frequent phone use on the morning the singer died.
It is just one of the more than 300 pieces of evidence that were presented during the trial, which so far has lasted six weeks.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...-to-consider/2011/11/02/gIQAGl3keM_story.html
 
Murray shooting secret documentary?
Updated: 22:12, Wednesday November 2, 2011

Dr Conrad Murray has reportedly been filming a documentary.

The physician is currently standing trial for the involuntary manslaughter of Michael Jackson. It has been claimed Murray has sold the rights 'to his story' to a production company.

There are also reports that Murray has been interviewed daily during his trial for the documentary. It is being pitched to various television networks as a package which would also include a sit-down interview with Murray and a video diary.
'A news division that pays for the documentary will end up with a side deal of getting the sit-down with Conrad,' a source told the New York Post.
'It's crafted in such a way for a news division that doesn't pay for interviews. They have already filmed a long interview in case he's taken into custody.'

It has been claimed the package could fetch around $US1 million ($A970,921) but it is not known how much Murray would receive from the sale.
New York Post reports CNN was approached about the documentary, but declined. NBC is believed to be close to securing a deal, with a view to using it for the Today show.

However, television insiders aren't sure how much attention the interviews will attract if Murray is cleared of the charges.
'I question whether there is enough interest in him,' a competitor mused. 'It's more interesting if he's found not guilty.'

If Murray is found guilty he could face up to four years in prison and lose his medical licence.
Murray announced yesterday that he will not testify in the trial.

Both sides are expected to deliver their closing arguments this week.

A spokesman for Murray's lawyer, J Michael Flanagan, has declined to comment on the documentary reports.

http://www.skynews.com.au/showbiz/article.aspx?id=680846&vId=
 
Back
Top