Latest on MJJC

The Michael Jackson Chart Watch

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
Hey, no disrespect to Stevie
Click to expand...
oh, I didn't think you were disrespecting Stevie. No way!

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
. I consider him absolutely the equal of Michael.
Click to expand...
Hm, see this is where we definitely differ. I see Stevie as being above Michael. That's in MY universe, you understand. And I'm not saying that Michael isn't the sun, the moon and the stars to me. But Stevie is ... I don't even know what to say.

Actually, I literally don't know what to say. Am I saying that Stevie is more talented than Michael? I have no idea. I need to think about this.

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
It's just about the hysteria and the cheering clapping.
Click to expand...
Oh, that's Michael, no question. As a superstar, as a global phenomenon, as someone with an insane level of fame, as someone who reached heights of fame, success and artistic achievement that no-one could have predicted or even imagined - that's all Michael.

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
I've seen Motown 25. Stevie got praise and applause, accolades the whole time. But those Jackson's were like the people's choice the whole way through. Truly the Black Beatles at that point.
Click to expand...
I don't know what to say about this. Once Michael did his M25 solo routine I didn't even care about the rest. Not even my Stevie! Michael danced like he had never danced before. And I'm not talking about the moonwalk. I'm not even bothered about that. It was the whole routine. Mind blowing.

But Stevie in 1980? He was The Man. At least, he is if I'm writing the story, lol.
 
Agonum said:
Yes, because ‘The Jacksons’ would be an incorrect answer. Remember that he released his solo debut in 1972.
Click to expand...
Thank you. You are as attentive and accurate as ever. But this is not a fan issue. I asked a few non-fans a question for the sake of verification. And they knew exactly what I meant. The paradox of 1979 and 1980 did not confuse anyone. And out of the 10 respondents, none of them did not know any of the names. Half knew he sang somewhere and that was it. Best answer: "in some family band."
 
zinniabooklover said:
Hm, see this is where we definitely differ. I see Stevie as being above Michael.
Click to expand...
In the 60s and 70s absolutely, he was. There were several significant greats before MJ. (Very few after.) And for the first half of the 80s Stevie still had it. But, it was in the 90s that I didn't see Stevie doing quite such a great work as before. Meanwhile MJ starting with Bad and continuing through on to the 90s, he was just top tier. And then the student, became the master. A song like Get It was MJ inheriting the torch, the same way as Say Say Say and the like with Paul.

I still enjoy everything Stevie did but his prime was different to MJ's prime. But overall the trio of music, MJ, Prince and Stevie is what I consider.
 
Mister_Jay_Tee said:
In the 60s and 70s absolutely, he was.
Click to expand...
Tbf, @Nite Line 's original question was about whether Stevie was bigger than Michael in 1980. I say yes, other peeps say no. But things did change for Stevie as the 1980's progressed, for sure.

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
There were several significant greats before MJ. (Very few after.) And for the first half of the 80s Stevie still had it. But, it was in the 90s that I didn't see Stevie doing quite such a great work as before.
Click to expand...
I think it's fair to say most musicians have a peak period of creativity - often from their late teens to the late 20's or early 30's. After that the hits usually dry up. Sometimes the creativity goes, sometimes they retain it but it's never burning hot like it was when they were younger. So for Stevie, since he started in the early 60's, it's to be expected that the 90's would see him being a lesser force.

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
Meanwhile MJ starting with Bad and continuing through on to the 90s, he was just top tier. And then the student, became the master
Click to expand...
Yeah, that's how it usually goes. There's something lovely about the Stevie / Michael thing. I dunno, maybe bc we have those photos of Michael in the studio watching Stevie create a record. Maybe bc we have J5 backing vocals on You Haven't Done Nothin. Lovely quotes from Michael about how much he loves and admires Stevie. There's just something so cool, so lovely about it.

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
I still enjoy everything Stevie did but his prime was different to MJ's prime.
Click to expand...
oh, for sure but for me Stevie's prime is better bc it's more meaningful for me. It just always will be.

Mister_Jay_Tee said:
But overall the trio of music, MJ, Prince and Stevie is what I consider.
Click to expand...
My trio is Jimi, Stevie and Michael. In that order. You got me thinking about all of this today, lol. I listen to Michael way more than Jimi or Stevie but they are the masters so they are in prime position. I'll be thinking about this for a while yet!
 
Last edited:
filmandmusic said:
@zinniabooklover slightly surprised by Phil Collins’ 8 songs on that list, he is always overlooked when it comes to 80s iconic musicians. But this stat shows he is right up there.
Click to expand...
Agreed. I could not have predicted that. I might have expected him to have 4 or 5 songs on the list but not 8. He's too MOR for me but, y'know, gotta acknowledge an impressive result.

Michael with 13 songs. That is very pleasing.
 
Last edited:
zinniabooklover said:
Agreed. I could not have predicted that. I might have expected him to have 4 or 5 songs on the list but not 8. He's too MOR for me but, y'know, gotta acknowledge an impressive result.

Michael with 13 songs. That is very pleasing.
Click to expand...
He’s where I would’ve thought him to be . He was huge (“huuuge”!) in the 80’s.
 
Agonum said:
He’s where I would’ve thought him to be . He was huge (“huuuge”!) in the 80’s.
Click to expand...
oh, I know. Unfortunately I was there so I know. He's way too MOR for me. I didn't even like him as the lead singer for Genesis. He did a good enough job, don't get me wrong, just too boring for me although I had long gone off Genesis by then, anyway.

Wiki tells me this:
"He is one of only three recording artists, along with Paul McCartney and Michael Jackson, who have sold over 100 million records both as solo artists and separately as principal members of a band."

Fgs, why am I talking about Phil Collins! :eek:

Let me go and find some data for the thread, lol.
 
Last edited:
mj-spotify mid-year
albums :

Thriller :375,600,126- 3,696,001,228
bad :206,110,775- 2,241,249,928
off the wall :111,235,445- 1,080,616,770
dangerous :87,215,990- 933,294,587
history :72,490,128- 713,764,104
invincible :44,407,005- 292,754,903
 
mj-spotify mid-year
top-10 songs

billie jean :148,303,886
beat it :102,328,249
Chicago :65,490,626
smooth criminal :63,348,658
rock with you :49,562,761
Thriller :40,827,869
the way you make me feel :36,835,891
don't stop t'ill you get enough :35,279,514
they don't care about us :32,908,819
man in the mirror :29,841,650
 
MJ-YOUTUBE top-30
june-2023

BJ: 21M
SC: 12M
BI: 10,6M
TDCAU : 8,900,000
TH-LV: 6,900,000
RWY : 4M
RTT : 3,7M
DSTYGE : 3,4M
YANA : 3,4M
BOW : 3,100,000
ES : 3M
BAD : 2,900,000
TH-SV: 2,500,000
TWYMMF : 2,300,000
DD : 2,100,000
HTW : 2M
WYBT : 1,730,000
YRMW-LV : 1,640,000
LNFSG : 1,570,000
WII : 1,550,000
GITM : 1,350,000
MITM : 980,000
YRMW-SV : 950,000
SCR : 820,000
BAD-LV : 790,000
SD : 730,000
GH : 620,000
LMA : 570,000
SIM : 570,000
HMH : 550,000
 
MJ-YOUTUBE TOP-30 MID-YEAR

BJ: 111M
SC : 67M
BI : 58M
TDCAU : 49M
TH-LV : 41M
RTT : 23M
RWY : 22M
ES : 19,4M
DSTYGE : 19,2M
BOW: 19M
YANA : 18M
BAD-SV : 16M
TH-SV : 14,6M
TWYMMF : 13,6M
HTW : 13,3M
DD : 12,5M
YRMW-SV : 11,1M
LNFSG : 10,3M
WYBT : 10M
WII: 9,1M
GITM : 8,1M
MITM : 5,8M
SCR : 5,3M
YRMW: 4,9M
BAD-LV : 4,9M
SD : 4M
GH : 3,9M
LMA : 3,4M
SIM : 3,4M
HMH : 3,3M
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top