Latest on MJJC

HIStory vs Invincible: Track By Track

Gonetoosoon

Proud Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
1,657
Points
0
Location
Sydney, Australia
Okay so due to the response on the first album battle I thought I'd make a second one using the same format :)

If you haven't seen the thread.. You've got to vote track by track on the two albums which you think is best.. So 15 tracks vs 15 in this case! (I combined Heartbreaker and Invincible together..)

HIStory vs Invincible
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened

Here are mine:
-Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us
-Stranger In Moscow
-Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song
-Butterflies
-Speechless
-2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone
-Childhood
-Tabloid Junkie
-Cry
-The Lost Children
-Whatever Happens
-Smile

Invincible wins 8-7. Very hard!

What are your choices??
 
Scream
TDCAU
SIM
This Time Around
Earth Song
Butterflies
Money (it was extremely hard to choose between the two)
Come Together
YANA
Childhood (Another difficult choice because I'm not too crazy about either one of those songs)
Tabloid Junkie
2 Bad
HIStory
Whatever Happens
Threatened

HIStory wins by a pretty large margin.
 
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened


Invincible Wins 8-7 I LOVE HIStory too but I love Invincible more... I guess... :D

L.o.v.e.
Romi
 
What do you mean by: -They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible? We choose between three songs?
 
KingMikeJ said:
What do you mean by: -They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible? We choose between three songs?
Click to expand...

I combined Heartbreaker/Invincible so it was 15 tracks each. Considering the two have a similar style/beat I put them together. You have two options - TDCAU or Heartbreaker & Invincible.
 
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened
History8-7
wow . that was closer than i realised considering HIStory is my fave mj album...
but i'm a sucker for the ballads on invincible so...
 
I can't possibly choose between Scream and Unbreakable, that's cruel! :p

If I had too...

Scream
They Don't Care About Us
Stranger In Moscow
This Time Around
Earth Song
D.S.
Speechless
2,000 Watts
You Are Not Alone
Privacy
Tabloid Junkie
2 Bad
HIStory
Whatever Happens
Threatened

HIStory wins 10-5, that wasn't as hard as I thought it would be :lol:
 
Wow, that's hard...

-Scream
-They Don't Care About Us
-Stranger In Moscow
-Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song
-Butterflies
-Speechless
-2000 Watts
-You Are My Life
-Childhood
-Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad
-The Lost Children
-Whatever Happens
-Smile

8-7 to Invincible... way too hard choices for me!:D
 
-Scream
-Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Break Of Dawn
-Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song
-D.S
-Speechless
-Come Together
-You Are My Life
-Childhood
-Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad
-HIStory
-Whatever Happens
-Threatened

Invincible 8-7
Oh my :ph34r: it was SO hard!
 
Scream
They Don't Care About Us
Stranger In Moscow
Heaven Can Wait
Earth Song
Butterflies
Speechless
Come Together
You Are Not Alone
Childhood
Tabloid Junkie
2 Bad
HIStory
Whatever Happens
Smile

HIStory wins 11-4
 
-Scream
-They Don't Care About Us
-Stranger in Moscow - I like Break of Dawn but nothing can trample SIM
-This Time Around
-Earth Song - YRMW is very nice but can't compare to Earth Song
-D.S.
-Money
-2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone
-Childhood
-Tabloid Junkie
-2 Bad
-HIStory
-Hmm.. listen to Whatever Happens more often because it's more accessible but Little Susie is great... I'll go with Whatever Happens.
-Smile

13-2 for HIStory!
 
HIStory vs Invincible

-Scream
-They Don't Care About Us
-Stranger In Moscow
-Heaven Can Wait
-You Rock My World
-Butterflies
-Speechless
-Come Together
-You Are Not Alone
-Childhood
-Tabloid Junkie
-2 Bad
-The Lost Children
-Whatever Happens
-Threatened
 
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened

HIStory wins 8-7
 
HIStory vs Invincible
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened

I Love Invincible very, very much but it does not compare to the masterpieace of History!
 
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened

HIStory wins 11-4. Both are fantastic, but HIStory is a masterpiece.
 
Scream
They Don't Care About Us
Stranger In Moscow
Heaven Can Wait
Earth Song
Butterflies
Money
Come Together
You Are Not Alone
Childhood
Tabloid Junkie
2 Bad
HIStory
Whatever Happens
Smile


HIStory wins 12-3.
 
Unbreakable
They Don't Care About Us
Stranger In Moscow
This Time Around
You Rock My World
Butterflies
Speechless
2000 Watts
You Are Not Alone
Childhood
Don't Walk Away
2 Bad
HIStory
Whatever Happens
Threatened

Invincible 8 - HIStory 7, that took a while both amazing albums
 
-Scream
-They Don't Care About Us
-Stranger In Moscow
-This Time Around
-Earth Song
-Butterflies
-Speechless
-Come Together
-You Are My Life
-Childhood
-Tabloid Junkie
-Cry
-HIStory
-Whatever Happens
-Smile

HIStory wins 10-5
 
-Scream
-They Don't Care About Us
-Stranger In Moscow
-Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song
-Butterflies
-Speechless
-2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone
-Privacy
-Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad
-HIStory
-Little Susie
-Threatened

HIStory wins 8-7. Very tough indeed.
 
-Scream vs Unbreakable
-They Don't Care About Us vs Heartbreaker/Invincible
-Stranger In Moscow vs Break Of Dawn
-This Time Around vs Heaven Can Wait
-Earth Song vs You Rock My World
-D.S vs Butterflies
-Money vs Speechless
-Come Together. vs 2000 Watts
-You Are Not Alone vs You Are My Life
-Childhood vs Privacy
-Tabloid Junkie vs Don't Walk Away
-2 Bad vs Cry
-HIStory vs The Lost Children
-Little Susie vs Whatever Happens
-Smile vs Threatened

What's going on, Invincible beats HIStory 10-5! I would never have guessed!
 
1. Scream
2. They Don't Care About Us
3. Stranger In Moscow
4. This Time Around
5. Earth Song
6. D.S
7. Money
8. Come Together
9. You Are Not Alone
10. Childhood
11. Tabloid Junkie
12. 2 Bad
13. HIStory
14. Little Susie
15. Smile

HIStory - 15
Invincible - 0
 
analogue said:
1. Scream
2. They Don't Care About Us
3. Stranger In Moscow
4. This Time Around
5. Earth Song
6. D.S
7. Money
8. Come Together
9. You Are Not Alone
10. Childhood
11. Tabloid Junkie
12. 2 Bad
13. HIStory
14. Little Susie
15. Smile

HIStory - 15
Invincible - 0
Click to expand...

just couldn't help yourself, could you? :lol:
 
analogue said:
1. Scream
2. They Don't Care About Us
3. Stranger In Moscow
4. This Time Around
5. Earth Song
6. D.S
7. Money
8. Come Together
9. You Are Not Alone
10. Childhood
11. Tabloid Junkie
12. 2 Bad
13. HIStory
14. Little Susie
15. Smile

HIStory - 15
Invincible - 0
Click to expand...

Someone's an Invincible lover! :tease:
 
I just tried...but I really couldn't. I had a lot of "can't choose" responses so I just erased it. haha.
 
Unbreakable
They don't care about us
Stranger in Moscow
Heaven can wait
Earth Song
Butterflies
Money
2000 Watts
You are my life
Privacy
Don't walk away
Cry
The lost children
Whatever happens
Threatened

History: 4
Invincible: 11

Strange, because as an album I prefer History. :upside_down:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top