filmandmusic
Proud Member
- Joined
- Nov 30, 2021
- Messages
- 6,084
- Points
- 113
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
For a posthumous album, it is pretty goodSo 2 million would be considered good sales for Xscape?
+ Spotify massive successFor a posthumous album, it is pretty good
Yes, the initial success of LNFSG and the recent success of Chicago means that Xscape was a success.+ Spotify massive success
It really is. It's better than the Paul McCartney tracks for sure at least.Yeah, it's good but is it Off The Wall or Thriller good?
It got enough airplay to get 4 top 10 hits, two number 1s.Promo surely plays a part but did OTW receive lots of promo then? Genuine question…
As for his voice in 1980, was it that well known? We all know everything kickstarted in 1983 then even the Pope would have known MJ’s voice, not so sure about 1980.
You are definitely capping with this one nowI am convinced if you go on the streets right now and ask random people who the lead singer of the Jacksons is, many of them would not know it.
Was he bigger than Stevie Wonder in 1980?In 1980 MJ was the biggest black artist in the world. In 1984 he was the biggest period. But I will concede, Victory was the biggest album the Jacksons put out. Peaked at number 4. Best numbers for sure. 2300 Jackson Street barely made top 60. Triumph still got one point over Destiny but, you gotta understand, "black music" was still more niche than it is now. Waiting for Duran Duran to appear now and tell me over 40 examples of how I'm wrong of course...
OTW was the 3rd biggest selling album of 1980 in the US (and UK, also, I think). Pretty sure it was the biggest selling album by a Black artist for that year. That said, was Michael bigger than Stevie in influence or cultural impact? I would say, no. Master Blaster or even Happy Birthday made more impact than the OTW singles, imo. Michael had definitely arrived as a solo artist, no question. People knew who he was. They knew his voice. But bigger than Stevie at that particular moment? I really don't think he was.Was he bigger than Stevie Wonder in 1980?
Regardless, I am sure that MJ was a big star after the release of Off The Wall in 1980. But I would say that he only became a household name after the release of Thriller and the debut of moonwalk.
[…] Waiting for Duran Duran to appear now and tell me over 40 examples of how I'm wrong of course...
Yes, because ‘The Jacksons’ would be an incorrect answer. Remember that he released his solo debut in 1972.It would be interesting to know the answer to "Which band did Michael sing in before his solo career?" I think few will answer The Jacksons.
Just an idea.
That’s just nitpicking considering 80% of his fans don’t recognize his solo Motown albums. This is not a fact but i’m sure it is damn closeYes, because ‘The Jacksons’ would be an incorrect answer. Remember that he released his solo debut in 1972.
Nitpicking? With four albums and a best of-compilation, I really don’t think so. But even if you were to completely ignore his solo Motown output, ‘The Jacksons’ would still be an incorrect answer. When Triumph (1980) was released, he had already released Off the Wall (1979). Thus, the only valid answer to the question “Which band did Michael sing in before his solo career?” (emphasis added), is The Jackson Five.That’s just nitpicking considering 80% of his fans don’t recognize his solo Motown albums. This is not a fact but i’m sure it is damn close
I can't argue thatNitpicking? With four albums and a best of-compilation, I really don’t think so. But even if you were to completely ignore his solo Motown output, ‘The Jacksons’ would still be an incorrect answer. When Triumph (1980) was released, he had already released Off the Wall (1979). Thus, the only valid answer to the question “Which band did Michael sing in before his solo career?” (emphasis added), is The Jackson Five.
At that point I'd say yes.Was he bigger than Stevie Wonder in 1980?
Here we are again, Mr JT. We'll have to agree to disagree on this one.At that point I'd say yes.
Yes, it was the start of Stevie's 'slightly lesser' '80's period. But that is a separate thing, imo, from the album itself. Just for Master Blaster alone, Songs/Key/Life was huge. Like you said, the whole album was huge. Politically SO important. For the UK, at that moment, I still say Stevie was bigger and way more important that Michael. Stevie never had the pandemonium that Michael had but there are many ways to measure a person's influence and importance. He had been our voice all through the '70's - arguably more important than Marvin although that's a closer competition than Stevie / Michael.Songs in the Keys of Life was huge but that was the start of Stevie's slightly lesser 80s period.
Sales wise it couldn't compete with OTW. That's as far as I can go on this point.Hotter than July had nothing on Off The Wall.
Yep, great footage, love it. But I'm standing by my man! Fan hysteria isn't everything. Not for me, anyway.
And here you can already see the Pandemonium.
Hey, no disrespect to Stevie. I consider him absolutely the equal of Michael. It's just about the hysteria and the cheering clapping. I've seen Motown 25. Stevie got praise and applause, accolades the whole time. But those Jackson's were like the people's choice the whole way through. Truly the Black Beatles at that point.Here we are again, Mr JT. We'll have to agree to disagree on this one.
Respectfully, of course!
Yes, it was the start of Stevie's 'slightly lesser' '80's period. But that is a separate thing, imo, from the album itself. Just for Master Blaster alone, Songs/Key/Life was huge. Like you said, the whole album was huge. Politically SO important. For the UK, at that moment, I still say Stevie was bigger and way more important that Michael. Stevie never had the pandemonium that Michael had but there are many ways to measure a person's influence and importance. He had been our voice all through the '70's - arguably more important than Marvin although that's a closer competition than Stevie / Michael.
Master Blaster only managed No.2 in the UK charts but, then again, it only made it to No.5 in the Billboard Hot 100. I'm not forgetting that it was at No.1 on the R&B chart for 7 weeks.
7 weeks!!![]()
![]()
I'm standing up for my man!
Sales wise it couldn't compete with OTW. That's as far as I can go on this point.
Yep, great footage, love it. But I'm standing by my man! Fan hysteria isn't everything. Not for me, anyway.
1980? Stevie all the way.
"They couldn't touch us even if they tried"
(oh god, now I've made myself cry)