zinniabooklover
Proud Member
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2022
- Messages
- 25,458
- Points
- 113
[...] They didnt even know it was filmed until we gave them that info. [...]
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
[...] They didnt even know it was filmed until we gave them that info. [...]
Like you, I listen to The Toy and Who Do You Know on a frequent basis. The rest, not so much.Do people still listen to the demos on disc 2? Ngl, The Toy and Who Do You Know are the only songs I go back to, the rest I didn't give much of a thought after the album's release.
I used to be disappointed with Who Do You Know because I expected it to be an uptempo song but after a few weeks it completely grew on me. I'm so glad the Estate was generous enough to give us an unheard song for the album (not only 1, but 2!).Like you, I listen to The Toy and Who Do You Know on a frequent basis. The rest, not so much.
Yeah the estate said they haven't found it in a Q&A few years ago. They didnt even know it was filmed until we gave them that info. I wish they asked Frank back In 2012 before he passed.
I would LOVE to just ramble thru all of that!Prince had an actual, physical vault at his house, i.e., a climate-controlled room with an alarm system and a secure door. After recording, whether it's a song or film reels of a concert, it would all go in there:![]()
![]()
Michael left things at studios (after he died, some unreleased music was found at recording studios such as Marvin's Room in LA) or with people who worked on them (video material, multitrack recordings) from musicians to studio support staff. He didn't catalog or organize much of anything in his life. If he needed something, he would usually have someone hunt it down for him. He seemed to be quite messy and disorganized even when living at Neverland:
![]()
The fact that he moved from house to house in the final years of his life didn't help.
How tf do they find out information thru us & never give what we beg for.... that means they listen & still don't gafYeah the estate said they haven't found it in a Q&A few years ago. They didnt even know it was filmed until we gave them that info. I wish they asked Frank back In 2012 before he passed.
The Estate has it.....they just don't want to go through the trouble of editing.....just like they're sitting on the Triumph show from LA on full film.
IIRC Queen (Brian May And Roger Taylor) wanted to release all the songs MJ and Freddie worked on but got vetoed by the Estate. They finally came to some kind of agreement to release TMBMTLTT.For example who could be in possession of the unfinished and only co written Mercury/Jackson track Victory? Considering both are gone, could it be lost forever?
Isn't Victory just a slamming toilet beat anyway?IIRC Queen (Brian May And Roger Taylor) wanted to release all the songs MJ and Freddie worked on but got vetoed by the Estate. They finally came to some kind of agreement to release TMBMTLTT.
According to interviews with Freddie they recorded a real demo of the song so I don’t think it’s just a slamming toilet beat.Isn't Victory just a slamming toilet beat anyway?
Freddie said it was about 5 min long so it seems pretty thought out, I guess it will sound rudimentary due to a lack of available instruments while recording but definitely something that could be fixed into a releasable song.Isn't Victory just a slamming toilet beat anyway?
Warren confirmed that at least 1 wembley show was completely filmed. He even had a VHS copy of it. I'm hoping the estate found it, otherwise where the hell did that HD victory tour LA film come from lol I bet they just now found it and digitized it.According to Warren Eagles, who was hired to edit the Wembley material, they had stacks of 35mm and 16mm reels but none of the shows were completely recorded on film. Minneapolis has performances on film since that's where the bulk footage of MITM from Moonwalker comes from.
Patrick Kelly said he turned in all the footage recorded from the tour after the last show.
The Estate has it.....they just don't want to go through the trouble of editing.....just like they're sitting on the Triumph show from LA on full film.
Well, there ya go. It's just an interesting oddity, maybe a cool idea to make something out of, like a interlude or whatever. But not a full blown tune.There was a person on the Queen forums who interviewed Peter Freestone and he said it was a rough ad-lib improvisation with Peter slamming the toilet door, if it's true it's in no way releasable. The demo of State Of Shock might just be the gem of the Freddie Mercury sessions.
I don't think you can post direct links to other forums here but it's discuss.queenonline.By any chance can you find that forum?
Is it this one? I could never tell if it was fan-made or not.Brian said they made a "Queen" version which he hopes to be able to release one day.
Is it this one? I could never tell if it was fan-made or not.
Official or not though, it's a hell lot better than that William Orbit mix.
Afaik both Forum nights are on Umatic.just like they're sitting on the Triumph show from LA on full film.
So why would an entire album be named after Victory when it not only didn't make the album, but was so rudimentary as to be considered totally unreleaseable in its original form?There was a person on the Queen forums who interviewed Peter Freestone and he said it was a rough ad-lib improvisation with Peter slamming the toilet door, if it's true it's in no way releasable. The demo of State Of Shock might just be the gem of the Freddie Mercury sessions.
First time hearing this, I hate the Orbit mix. This is indeed a lot better BUT still a below par song, I don’t even like Michaels’s vocals much.Is it this one? I could never tell if it was fan-made or not.
Official or not though, it's a hell lot better than that William Orbit mix.
I'm sure we'll get to see them by 2032I just hope The Estate at least digitilize all the footage they have.
All VHS, tapes, 16 mm, 32 mm or what they have. - Convert it to digital so quality is saved forever. I really do not hope they just leave it be and do nothing to save it.
I don't really care if we have to wait. - Just it would be nice to know if the Estate actually do convert it to digital, do they make sure all tapes, VHS and films are converted to best possible quality and saved digitally. - If so it is also easy to organice. So the archive would be easy.I'm sure we'll get to see them by 2032
But why does the Estate have to pay money to the producers for the material if they owe the rights themselves?The Estate has the sole rights to publish this material, i.e. the material cannot be released by anyone other than the Estate. The collaborators are asking for money to hand it over. The Estate is currently not interested in releasing it, so there is no reason for them to pay anyone to hand it over.
My thoughts exactly!But why does the Estate have to pay money to the producers for the material if they owe the rights themselves?
I think if they had released MJ's solo version after his death it would be a smash hit/Christmas classic. IMHO it's alsmost as haunting as 'Imagine'. No further instrumentation neededFirst time hearing this, I hate the Orbit mix. This is indeed a lot better BUT still a below par song, I don’t even like Michaels’s vocals much.